John Hawkins on The Media Bias Factor:
From the NYT:
<<<
Mr. Brown's version of events raises questions about whether the White House and Mr. Chertoff acted aggressively enough in the response. New Orleans convulsed in looting and violence after the hurricane, and troops did not arrive in force to restore order until five days later."
>>>
This is a fascinating meme and I'll tell you why.
The original meme pushed by the media after things
started to break down in New Orleans was that FEMA, and
by extension the Bush administration, were supposed to be
first responders, and therefore they were responsible for
every mistake that was made.
Unfortunately, this meme was out there for almost a week
because most conservatives, driven by a sense of decency,
didn't want to start pointing fingers while people were
still being rescued.
However, conservatives eventually started speaking up and
pointed out that the locals, not FEMA, were supposed to
be the first responders. Then, one screw-up after another
that had absolutely nothing to do with FEMA were
revealed. Nagin didn't follow the city's evacuation plan.
He didn't use city buses to get people out of New
Orleans. The state blocked the Red Cross from coming in
to feed the people at the Superdome. Blanco was slow to
call out the National Guard, etc., etc., etc.
At that point, the media had a dilemma to deal with.
They had already spent a solid week screaming to everyone
who'd listen that this whole mess was Bush and FEMA's
fault and yet, as the days went on, it became
increasingly obvious that Blanco and Nagin were the root
of the problems in New Orleans.
Which brings us to where we are today.
If the liberal MSM were to correct itself at this point,
it would not only be embarrassing, it would require
shifting the "finger of blame" from the hated Bush
administration to two Democrats. Of course, that would
never do.
So, what the MSM has done instead is shift the goalposts
and blame the Bush administration for not realizing
Blanco and Nagin were inept overwhelmed sooner. This is a
perversely brilliant tactic, because no matter what
happens, the Bush Administration is always at fault. Did
FEMA screw something up that was actually their
responsibility? Then FEMA gets the blame. Did Blanco or
Nagin screw something up? Then FEMA gets the blame for
that, too, because they should have immediately realized
that Blanco and Nagin didn't know what they were doing.
That sort of, "d*mned if you do, d*mned if you don't,"
coverage for the Bush administration is typical of how
the MSM has handled Katrina's aftermath. For example...
Bush was too slow to fly over to New Orleans? That means
he's a big jerk who doesn't care! Bush flies over New
Orleans? What good is a fly-over? He may as well have
just watched it on TV. Bush actually goes to New Orleans
and talks to people on the ground? Oh, he's just looking
to get some good publicity photos!
It's as if the MSM's hurricane coverage started out with
a premise of "How can we use Katrina to stick it to
Bush?" and then they worked from there. You know, in
retrospect, even if they didn't start out with that
premise, would the mainstream media coverage have been
significantly different if they had? The honest answer to
that question is "no"...
http://www.rightwingnews.com/archives/week_2005_09_11.PHP#004421
nytimes.com