The NYT is "still spinning after all these years."
Still Fighting the 'Swift Boat' Battle
THE CAUCUS
NYT BLOG
By Kate Zernike
For most people, "Swift Boat" has become a political verb, a synonym for the kind of attack that helped destroy Senator John Kerry's presidential campaign in 2004.
But for a group of Vietnam veterans at the center of the attacks, it's still a fresh fight.
Friday, a group of veterans who served with Mr. Kerry in Vietnam sent a letter to T. Boone Pickens, the billionaire Texas oilman who helped finance the attack ads in 2004, taking him up on a challenge issued last November: that he'd give a million dollars to anyone who could disprove a single charge the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth made against Mr. Kerry.
The letter-writers served alongside Mr. Kerry during the incidents that the Swift Boat group insisted he had embellished or made up to win his military decorations.
Identifying themselves as "patriotic, concerned veterans" they say the accusations (their words: "the lies") of the Swift Boat group damaged their reputations and deeply affected their families, "tarnished the sacrifices we made, called into question the medals we were awarded and challenged the very authenticity of our service."
The group is working with Mr. Kerry, who himself seized on the challenge soon after Mr. Pickens made it at an American Spectator dinner. In a letter, he offered to meet with Mr. Pickens to rebut the charges. Mr. Pickens wrote back to say he was good for his money, but that Mr. Kerry would have to provide his military record, the journal he kept during Vietnam, and all copies of movies and tapes made during his tours there.
Mr. Pickens also qualified his challenge, saying he meant that someone would have to prove false things in the group's television ads – putting aside the bestselling book and extensive media interviews that attracted them the bulk of the attention. He challenged Mr. Kerry back: if you can't prove anything inaccurate, give $1 million to the Medal of Honor Foundation, a charity.
Wait a minute, Mr. Kerry wrote back, you said nothing at the dinner about just the ads. (At least, that's how blogs sympathetic to Mr. Pickens quoted his challenge.) He said he'd meet with Mr. Pickens – "no variations, no back peddling, no retreat, no new bets, no changing the subject" – and direct his reward money to a charity that helps veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Mr. Pickens did not reply.
So Mr. Kerry's veteran allies took up the cause. In a 12-page letter – with a 42-page attachment of military records to support their case — they rebut not one but several of the accusations the Swift Boat group.
The veterans offer to go through Mr. Kerry's record and the video with Mr. Pickens "page by page, frame by frame." And they demand an apology, to them "and to the American people."
Of course, none of this is really new. Extensive media accounts undermined the Swift Boat charges in 2004, pointing out that some of the Swift Boat critics had written statements during Vietnam lauding Mr. Kerry for extraordinary bravery in the incidents they later said he made up. (One accuser in particular had become upset by his portrayal in a Kerry biography in 2004.) One critic had himself received a medal for heroism during a hail of gunfire he later claimed Mr. Kerry had concocted to win his third purple heart.
But that did not blunt the political impact.
Mr. Kerry has remained determined to set the record straight. And the other side remains similarly fixed. So those charities are unlikely to see their million.
A spokesman for Mr. Pickens, Jay Rosser, said the package had not arrived late Friday. Mr. Pickens — who has said he won't participate in partisan politics this presidential cycle – was traveling and could not be reached for comment. thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com |
