Fournier is AP's top political writer. It is astounding to
see him write this strong a criticism of Kerry. I guess he
can't take the crap anymore.- -From: LindyBill
<font size=4>
Critics Attack Kerry's Iraq Troops Plan
<font size=3>
By RON FOURNIER, AP Political Writer
WASHINGTON - <font size=4>John Kerry (news - web sites) says he can <font color=blue>"put a deal together"<font color=black> as president to drastically reduce U.S. troop strength in Iraq (news - web sites), a pledge reminiscent of Richard Nixon's secret plan to end the Vietnam War and Dwight D. Eisenhower's promise to stop fighting in Korea.
Like those Republican presidential candidates, the Democrat's blueprint for peace lacks detail and has critics squawking.
With voters skittish about the death toll in Iraq, Kerry is pinning blame on President Bush and his shaky relationships with allies who have refused to support U.S. troops with soldiers of their own. The four-term Massachusetts senator suggests he has back-channel assurances that foreign leaders would do more if he were president.
<font color=blue>
"There is a potential to be able to put a deal together over the course of time,"<font color=black> Kerry told The Associated Press in his first interview as the Democratic nominee. <font color=blue>"At least, that is the perception that smart people like Joe Biden and, you know, Carl Levin and other leaders who've been there for a long time." <font color=black>
He said his fellow Democratic senators, reporting on their foreign travels, have told him, <font color=blue>"A change in the presidency is essential to our ability to restore our respect and relationship."<font color=black>
<font color=red>
But when asked for hard evidence that his victory would produce a troops-reducing deal for America, neither Kerry nor his fellow senators cite anything other than their vague perceptions and utmost hopes.
<font color=blue>
"I can't give you the details of any deal, obviously,"<font color=black> Sen. Carl Levin (news, bio, voting record), D-Mich., said Monday. <font color=blue>"You don't negotiate a deal until you have a leader who is there to negotiate a deal."<font color=black>
Levin said he has talked to foreign leaders about potential changes in their Iraq policies after the U.S. election. <font color=blue>"Nobody is going to say what the details of the deal are. They simply report to us that distrust of the administration is so intense that you can't take a risk"<font color=black> and deploy troops to Iraq, he said.
<font color=blue>
"I'm not going to tell you which foreign leaders, because I'd be breaking the confidence of foreign leaders that I've met,"<font color=black> said Levin, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee (news - web sites). Last spring, Kerry said foreign leaders preferred him to Bush, though he also refused to identify any.
Levin wavered on the question of whether any foreign leader promised to get more involved in Iraq if Kerry wins. <font color=blue>"It seems to be that's the basic implication,"<font color=black> he said at first.
<font color=red>
But has any leader made a commitment?
No, he replied.
<font color=blue>
"I'm not in position nor should I attempt to negotiate with a foreign government,"<font color=black> Levin said.
Sen. Joseph Biden (news, bio, voting record), D-Del., a top Kerry adviser, thinks Kerry could sway allies better than the president, said spokesman Norm Kurz. But that's only hypothetical — <font color=blue>"I don't think there's a guarantee,"<font color=black> he said.
Kerry is only the latest presidential candidate to offer unspecified plans for peace.
<font size=3>
In 1952, Eisenhower was running against Democrat Adlai Stevenson to replace unpopular incumbent Harry Truman when he promised to <font color=red>"concentrate on the job of ending the Korea war. ... That job requires a personal trip to Korea,"<font color=black> he said. <font color=red>"I shall go to Korea." <font color=black>
Truman called the pledge a <font color=blue>"desperate attempt to get votes."<font color=black> When Eisenhower went to Korea between his Election Day victory and his inauguration, Truman called it <font color=blue>"a piece of demagoguery."<font color=black>
<font size=4>
Republicans are just as tough on Kerry.
<font color=red>
"John Kerry has an enormous lack of credibility on this issue,"<font color=black> said Bush spokesman Steve Schmidt.
Anthony Cordesman, an Iraq expert with the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said Kerry's plan assumes too much.
<font color=red>
"Nobody is going to bail us out of our responsibilities in this conflict,"<font color=black> said Cordesman, former adviser to Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz. <font color=red>"It is not a matter of who is the president at this point. There simply won't be any international support for a country like France or Germany to do it." <font color=blue>
Kerry voted against the first Persian Gulf War, which threw Saddam Hussein out of Kuwait in 1991. Eleven years later, he voted to give Bush authority to use force against Saddam, then voted against a bill to help pay for the conflict as anti-war sentiment threatened to undermine his bid for the Democratic nomination.
<font color=black><font size=3>
In 1968, Nixon sought political gain from anti-war fervor when he touted a secret plan to end the Vietnam War.
<font size=4>
Kerry, a decorated veteran of that conflict, reminds some of Nixon when he talks of vague deals with foreign leaders.
<font color=blue>
"I don't care what it sounds like,"<font color=black> Kerry told ABC. <font color=blue>"The fact is that I'm not going to negotiate in public today without the presidency."<font color=black>
<font size=3>
The Vietnam War ended after Nixon left office. Eisenhower oversaw the 1953 Korean War armistice. The insurgency in Iraq shows no sign of easing, with two U.S. soldiers killed Monday and bombers on Tuesday killing three Iraqi national guardsmen, a police chief and a patrolman.
EDITOR'S NOTE — Ron Fournier has covered national politics and the White House since 1993.
Copyright © 2004 The Associated Press. |
