Tango,
Regarding Taiwan try my post #6513, unfortunately the URL listed only works for the day it's printed (I found this out today) because it is a daily news service. Amati's modems were included, as well as Westell. They mentioned Taiwan's extensive copper-wire investment and were very enthusiatic about ADSL.
The Following was from that news source so I won't include the URL again. It states that Alcatel doesn't have the last word on the gang of four contract. Good news for Westell and Amati:
<<MAJOR ALLIANCE FORMS TO BATTLE ALCATEL FOR ADSL PROVISION IN THE UNITED STATES
Source: ISDN NEWS
ISDN NEWS via Individual Inc. -- When Paris-based Alcatel Telecom won a request for proposal (RFP) in October to develop an asymmetric digital subscriber line (ADSL) solution for a consortium of four baby Bells, that did not sit well with equipment manufacturers in North America. But, no one is throwing in the towel yet. BellSouth , PacBell , Ameritech, and Southwestern Bell have said they can still buy ADSL modems and products from other companies, which has stirred a move from Westell Technologies and Nortel.
In early November, the two companies penned an agreement jointly to develop a turnkey ADSL solution for carriers and Internet service providers (ISPs). "This is a direct response to the decision of the joint procurement consortium," says Broadband Consultant Kieren Taylor of TeleChoice, Verona, N.J. "Alcatel was selected because it can provide an end-to-end solution, from the consumer's modem to the central office. The consortium wanted this level of integration."
On their own, neither Westell or Nortel is ready to manufacture a turnkey package, Taylor reports. Westell has focused on ADSL modems, while Nortel has targeted central office gear and private branch exchanges (PBXs). "They could have an advantage in the North American market together," adds Taylor. "From a pure service point of view, they have tons of manpower in the area. Alcatel would have to do a lot of hiring to catch up. This alliance is a very significant development for the marketplace."
For its part, Nortel says the decision to team with Westell was easy. "Westell has the No. 1 deployed ADSL modem in the U.S. right now," explains Gary Bolton, Nortel's senior manager of ADSL business management. "We have also had a teaming agreement with Westell over the past year. We have pulled together parts of our product lines on occasion to respond to RFPs. The difference is, we are now doing joint systems development within a more formal alliance."
"We have identified a whole range of areas we could work on with Nortel," says Rob Saw, president of global operations at Westell. "We're even looking at joint manufacturing. Our initial focus will be on providing a complete ADSL solution for telcos and ISPs, but even where you have PBXs, there is an opportunity for ADSL to be terminated. It's feasible, but not our initial focus right now." Campus environments may be able to use PBXs in conjunction with ADSL for remote LAN access and other functions, he adds.
...Westell and Nortel to Side-Step an ADSL Dispute
What will the ADSL system produced by Nortel and Westell look like? The equipment manufacturers are trying to avoid entanglement in an industry controversy over which line modulation standard should be used for ADSL. "We're line-code agnostic," Bolton reports. "We're going to be independent and support both of the major line modulation standards in the field, discrete multi-tone (DMT) and carrierless amplitude phase (CAP)."
This will surprise some because the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) has only approved DMT as a line modulation standard for ADSL, and Westell has deployed CAP-based modems to date. But, "Bell Atlantic, Nynex , and U S West are all pushing ANSI to make CAP a standard," says Bolton. "Nearly all of the ADSL modems deployed today are CAP-based. Between 10,000 and 12,000 lines of CAP are on the market, with less than 2,000 lines of DMT. ANSI will feel a lot of pressure to make this change."
"Westell is one of the first customers of DMT for Motorola," Saw says. But, considering that CAP is used in 90 percent of deployed ADSL products, it may already be a de facto standard, he adds.
The new solution will include everything from the Westell FlexCap ADSL modem to the Nortel Passport, Concorde, and Vector ATM switches. Nortel has also proposed to bundle in its Entrust family of encryption and digital signature services to provide security to computer networks using ADSL. And, Nortel will offer its service controller systems, which manage switched and permanent virtual circuits.
New Westell modems can also be expected, says Saw. "We want to support everything from 384 Kbps [symmetrical digital subscriber lines] to [very high-rate digital subscriber lines]," he explains. "VDSL will operate at 12 Mbps downstream, and 1 Mbps upstream. But, customers have to be close to the central office, or carriers must run neighborhood hubs out to meet them."
Interestingly, both Westell's and Alcatel's solutions use ATM as the ADSL backbone. "ATM offers an economy of scale that will be needed once ISPs start pumping Web pages to end-users at 1.5 Mbps or more," says TeleChoice's Taylor. "Frame technology won't give them (telcos and ISPs) the same type of multimedia coverage."
A Westell ADSL modem currently costs $1,500 to $2,000, Saw says. But, the cost should drop to about the $1,000 level at the beginning of 1997, and the $500 level by the end of '97. During 1998, consumers could see Westell modems in the $300 to $500 range, Saw predicts. (Contact: Nortel, 919-992-7851; Westell Technologies, 813-376-9666; TeleChoice, 201-239-0700) *
[12-03-96 at 18:00 EST, Copyright 1996, Phillips Publishing, Inc.]>>
Regards,
Richard |