It's NOT the Economy, Stupid: It's the Mess in Washington
Despite all the worry about the sluggish US economy, businesses and investors are finding an even bigger reason to be cautious these days: the political mess in Washington.
AP
"Businesses—especially smaller businesses, independent businesses—they don't know what their cost structures are going to be because of government-imposed changes," David Kotok, founder of Cumberland Advisors, said on CNBC this week. "Half the US economy's holding back because of this great uncertainty that's coming from Washington."
Investors, too, are holding back, with control of Congress up for grabs in November and the possibility of sharp policy changes after that. Market pros cite a number of issues—the Bush tax cuts, possible repeal of health care reform, the deficit—for all the unease.
The market, in fact, has basically moved sideways all summer, with the Standard & Poor's 500 [.SPX Loading... () ] virtually unchanged since May 25. Investors, meanwhile, have fled equity funds and plowed money into bonds.
Jeff Cox
Staff Writer
CNBC.com
"Why are we stuck in this range? It’s not the (economic growth) issue," says Nadav Baum, executive vice president at BPU Investment Management in Pittsburgh. "It’s the issue of what’s going to happen in November with the election and what’s going to happen with the Bush tax cuts. You’ve got all this uncertainty and…when there’s more uncertainty, people get more uncomfortable with equities."
Some pros, like Keith Springer, president of Capital Financial Advisory Services, think investors would be just fine with the kind of legislative gridlock that gripped Washington in the mid-1990s, when then-President Bill Clinton battled with a Republican-controlled Congress.
In fact, Springer predicts a strong rally if the Republicans manage to take control of at least one congressional chamber after the November election.
"There's a push-pull in the market right now where nobody wants to go through the pain of what we need to get the economy back in shape," he said. "But at the same time nobody wants to stop spending money to make it better."
Key Points
Both investors and business owners are unwilling to commit new money until the November election.
Some pundits believe Wall Street actually wants gridlock in Washington.
Investors like gridlock in Washington partly because it removes the possibility of major changes being made that could rattle the landscape.
When the GOP wrested control from the Democrats in the 1994 mid-term elections, the previously moribund S&P 500 gained 34 percent in 1995, another 20 percent in 1996, 31 percent in 1997, 27 percent in 1998 and 19.5 percent in 1999 before hitting a wall in 2000.
"Gridlock would probably make this market soar," Springer says.
In the interim, investors have been trying to outfox the market, employing a buy-the-dips sell-the-rallies stock strategy and going full-bore into bonds.
Many investors have been looking to the Federal Reserve for direction, trying to stay ahead of the central bank as it continues measures, such as buying Treasurys, to boost money flow in the economy, says Kotok of Cumberland Advisors.
"The Fed does not do these trades in isolation," Kotok said in a note to clients earlier this week. "The rest of the world is watching, trading, investing, swapping, hedging, and attempting to front-run the Fed's tsunami every single minute." |
