1. Individual Americans have the right to bear arms. This is the clear intent of the
Founding Fathers in many of the papers and articles they wrote outside of the Bill of
Rights, and for excellent reasons.
Really? Can you cite one court decision affirming this? Do you know how to diagram a sentence? For example, the one about the well-armed militia? A scant understanding of the threats to America at that time would help in understanding this concept. Also, the guns of the time were very inaccurate muskets, not particularly lethal. It is insane to me to argue that the Founding Fathers, coming back somehow now, would approve of 200 million handguns in this society, massacres in schools, and an incredible social pathology attached to the gun problem which makes our society an international laughing stock. As visionaries, I know they would do better.
2. Yes, a populace well-armed can stand off an army: look at Pakistani guerillas holding
back the Russians, or the Viet Cong holding off the Americans, or other examples
throughout history.
A well-armed populace in jungle or mountainous terrain well-known to them but relatively unknown to an enemy can stand off an army for some period of time, particularly if the army is unwilling to use substantial force. The Russian army is a joke, and the Americans in Vietnam had their hands tied in using the kind of force needed to win because of an eroding political will back home. None of these factors would influence an American political force which had somehow managed to harness our own armed forces.
3. Pacifists rely on the goodwill of others to protect them.
I am not a pacifist. I believe in military might as a deterrent force. That is very different from supporting the need of every American to have individual Uzis. In your support for guns, you totally overlook the pathology they create. What is freedom for, if there is no freedom to walk down the streets unassaulted? We have the world's highest rate of death by guns, per capita, so there is a significant social cost attached.
4. It is every individual's duty, ultimately, to be responsible for (and defend) their own
property, including their life. Urban lifestyle is an illusion in the pocket of a greater
illusion surrounded by reality.
You are sounding like one of those survivalist militia types. Are you? Most Americans live in cities. All security is ultimately illusory, but urban reality is certainly no stranger on a day-to-day basis than a bunch of angry losers doing paramilitary exercises in the countryside, shooting abortion-clinic doctors and bombing Federal buildings in their spare time. |
