To me it is just as simple...
RedHat has to choose a relatively small number of packages to include in the main CD, or else the distro will grow entirely too big. For a graphics viewing package with thumbnails, it can choose:
1) XV - which would eliminate one of their main selling points for the RedHat CD... that each program on it is free for both commercial and non-commercial use, with source included and free to modify/redistribute.
2) ee or Eye of Gnome - which uses the same libraries already in use for the default desktop, leading to less memory usage and a consistant look-and-feel.
This is a no-brainer.
Also, it is not like they are depriving anyone of the technology, because the xv packages are available for download to the people who want them. You can even make your own CD that includes RedHat+XV (I know a fellow in Florida that does this, calling it "RedHack").
If John Bradley wanted a wider distribution of his program, then he could easily lift the restrictions on commercial use. It's unfair to blame RedHat for John's choices.
JMHO,
-Mitch |
