CTC
You make some very persuasive arguments, and certainly seem to have a better grip on CFFO, FV and PV. Very useful tools in putting a value on a company's current operations. But not very useful in predicting the future value. You can try these measures on Ampex, but not Amazon. Or, Yahoo!, Cisco or Citrix. These stocks are volatile but that's not the same thing as risky.
I am not an accountant so I'll never be able to ascertain your CFFO and PV/FV computations. I assume they are right. I do believe that there are different scaling factors for relative market positions. So, two companies making exactly the same widgets and growing at same rate will have different multipliers depending on who's the leader. Your formulae need some tweaking to capture this market fact.
Re. the Nobel Laureates (sp) and other market experts whom you so eloquently quote. Personally, I think if somebody found the way to a hidden gold mine, very unlikely he or she is going to show the path to the rest of us. So, those who talk either don't know, or are unsure. Especially in the world of money where access to resources is not much of an issue as, one might argue, it is in the world of gold mining.
(this is not to say that these are not intelligent people.)
Regards Dinesh |