Buena Vista Clinton Club?
Ry Cooder's Cuba Trip Questioned In
Clinton Controversy
Guitarist/producer gave $10,000 to Hillary Clinton's
campaign, then got OK to record in communist country.
Ry Cooder has been known for more than 30 years as a consummate musician and
as a passionate advocate and diligent archivist of music from around the world.
But lately, some suggest that he can now be regarded as a member of a newly
conspicuous and controversial group: donors to the campaign of U.S. Sen. Hillary
Clinton (D-NY) who received favors from Bill Clinton in the waning hours of his
presidency.
Last Saturday, guitarist/producer Cooder returned to the United States from
Cuba, having recorded with local musicians in Havana. All obstacles to traveling and
recording in Cuba, which is under a strict, four-decade-old U.S. embargo, were
removed due to the intervention of outgoing Clinton administration officials and
the president himself.
Coincidentally or not, as he was encountering problems securing
a license to record in Cuba last year, Cooder contributed
$10,000 to Hillary Clinton's victorious campaign to represent the
state of New York in the Senate.
Cooder's dispensation and contribution have come to light in the
context of Bill Clinton's exit from the White House, one that
many maintain occurred under a cloud of impropriety. But
others think any such connection is rubbish.
"Whatever one thinks of [Bill] Clinton's decisions to pardon
certain people or to accept gifts, or relate favors granted for
contributions received," said Rep. Howard Berman (D-California),
"tying that to this decision to give Ry Cooder a license to record
great aging Cuban musicians is absolute nonsense." Berman is
the author of a 1988 amendment to the Constitution allowing
international cultural exchanges, even with countries under
anti-democratic governments such as that of Cuba's leader,
Fidel Castro.
Candace Hanson, Cooder's lawyer, did not return a call for
comment at press time. Sen. Clinton's office has consistently
denied any knowledge of Cooder's traveling woes and any
connection.
Unlike the trip he made to the country in 1996 — which yielded
1997's massively popular, Grammy-winning Buena Vista Social
Club album, and for which he was fined $25,000 for recording
there without a license — Cooder's most recent jaunt to Cuba
was authorized by the U.S. State Department and licensed by
the U.S. Treasury Department, according to the Baltimore Sun.
Initially, the State Department's Cuban Affairs section refused to approve Cooder's
application, filed in January 2000, to return to Cuba. In August 2000, the
Department specified that he could return but could not share in profits resulting
from the sessions, which were conducted with guitarist Manuel Galban. Cooder did
not accept, and re-applied in November, according to the Sun.
But in the same flurry of pardons and favors meted out to the likes of fugitive
financier Marc Rich and first brother Roger Clinton, outgoing Secretary of State
Madeleine Albright and National Security Adviser Samuel Barber interceded on
Cooder's behalf on January 17, three days before President Bush's inauguration.
"It may very well be a coincidence," said Lawrence Nobles of the Center for
Responsive Politics, a Washington, D.C., organization focusing on campaign
finance reform. "Mr. Cooder has given campaign contributions to other candidates
(Democratic California Sens. Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein), but nothing this
large. What's more important is the problem with the whole system. You have
something that appears suspicious: He was first fined for going to Cuba, he puts
in an application, then contributes to Senator Clinton's campaign, and then his
application is approved.
"It may very well be that it was approved for valid reasons, and nobody in the line
for authorizing the approval knew about the contribution," Nobles continued. "The
problem here is that it looks like there may be [favoritism involved]."
Berman disagrees. "As long as we have a system of private financing of
campaigns," he said, "one can always question the motivation for any official
action. Carrying that logic to this decision is off-base."
"I have been involved in this case for [15] months, speaking to the State
Department, the Treasury department and National Security Department," he said.
"The reason this license wasn't granted sooner is about politics in Florida." The
powerful Cuban-American community in the Miami area is viscerally anti-Castro,
and is influential in perpetuating the embargo against Cuba.
"I believe that major policymakers like Albright and Berger thought it was crazy not
to let him go down there and record musicians whom Castro kept from performing
in front of their own people and to people around the world for years," he said.
If Berman offers any criticism regarding impropriety, he doesn't lay it at Cooder's
door, opting instead for an address in Chappaqua, New York. "When you've done
things that look suspicious, as occurred near the end of the [Clinton]
administration, you end up tainting a lot of decisions made for straightforward,
honest, noble purposes." Cooder plans to return to Havana in March to record with
Ibrahim Ferrer, a vocalist prominently featured on Buena Vista Social Club.
— Rob Kemp |
