re: m-Commerce - Nokia Says This and Simon Says That ...
>> Mass Market Ready and Waiting for Mobile Commerce, According to New Consumer Study for Nokia
Business Wire
May 23, 2001
Mobile commerce, or m-commerce, the ability to pay for goods and services by using a mobile phone, will be easily accepted by mobile telephony consumers, according to a new study announced today by Nokia. The study shows that many more people will be willing to use their mobile phones for m-commerce than presently use eCommerce to make purchases over the Internet. The study confirms that mobile operators can expect future revenue growth from m-commerce.
The study conducted by MORI, Britain's largest independent market research agency, found that roughly eight-times as many people would use m-commerce as compared to the number of people actually using eCommerce today. The study also showed that nearly 90% of people interested in using m-commerce services will also be willing to pay extra for the convenience of making purchases with m-commerce.
MORI interviewed over 11,000 people in six markets from October 2000 to January. The range of markets studied was global -- Great Britain, South Korea, Italy, USA, Brazil and Finland.
Nokia undertook the study to provide an end user perspective on m-commerce, which will likely be rolled out to some markets in the near future. In particular, Nokia aimed to gain insights into people's attitudes towards potential m-commerce services and applications, as well as insights into people's fears and obstacles preventing m-commerce usage. Finally, Nokia hoped to bolster the business case by showing that potential demand for m-commerce already exists in the marketplace.
The study revealed that mobile-phone users view m-commerce as complementary to alternative remote-commerce channels such as the Internet. They tend to favor ``local'' transactions, where m-commerce provides a unique application for electronic transactions. Their choice of payment method depends on the size of the transaction and billing arrangements, but most are willing to pay extra for m-commerce services. This suggests that consumers see real value and benefit in using their mobile phones as tools for shopping.
The study demonstrated that convenience and control will play a pivot role in acceptance of m-commerce. Study participants saw m-commerce as a way of avoiding carrying cash or waiting in queues, as well as a way to grain greater control over expenditures and enjoy unlimited purchasing possibilities. Future m-commerce users are unlikely to view specific goods and services as exclusively ``m-commerce products''. They will think in terms of situations, such as being lost or having a car breakdown, where they are willing to pay more for services available via m-commerce.
``It is clear from this study that the market sees m-commerce as a natural extension of eCommerce,'' said Reza Chady, Global Head of Market Research, Nokia Networks. ``While it is a new concept to many people, they are already expecting to use this method of payment in the future, which makes us feel confident that the potential mass market for m-commerce is huge.''
Specifically, the study found that initial adoption of m-commerce is likely to be on a similar scale as today's usage of eCommerce, which is already somewhat mature. Also, 24% to 54% of respondents across the markets stated they would be willing to carry out a transaction of more than USD 25 using a mobile device.
Nokia Network's market research is created by the WCDMA (Wideband Code Division Multiple Access) 3G Research Centre. The Research Centre provides professional global market research and market analysis. It is dedicated to delivering market research insight to Nokia Networks and its customers throughout the world.
The projects undertaken by the Research Centre include extensive analysis of usage and behaviour for 3G topics such as Mobile Internet, m-commerce, entertainment, mMarketing, tariffing, and enterprise / corporate services and applications. <<
... the other view:
>> Nokia Says Mass Market Ready For M-Commerce, Mobile Lifestreams Strongly Disagrees
Simon Buckingham
Mobile Lifestreams
23 May 2001
Mobile commerce, or m-commerce, the ability to pay for goods and services by using a mobile phone, will be easily accepted by mobile telephony consumers, according to a new study announced today by Nokia. The study shows that many more people will be willing to use their mobile phones for m-commerce than presently use eCommerce to make purchases over the Internet. The study confirms that mobile operators can expect future revenue growth from m-commerce.
MORI interviewed over 11,000 people in six markets from October 2000 to January. The range of markets studied was global -- Great Britain, South Korea, Italy, USA, Brazil and Finland.
Specifically, the study found that initial adoption of m-commerce is likely to be on a similar scale as today's usage of eCommerce, which is already somewhat mature. Also, 24% to 54% of respondents across the markets stated they would be willing to carry out a transaction of more than USD 25 using a mobile device.
Mobile Lifestreams strongly disagrees with the results of this research- it is interesting that this theoretical research comes about the same time as Amazon.com, THE leading e-Commerce company, wound down its M-Commerce activities and laid off many people associated with that effort within the company. This after Amazon.com had made very similar statements to Nokia above (indeed these statements were made in Nokia’s own customer magazine).
It is very easy to ask someone whether they would be interested in doing something in theory, getting them to the point where they are able to do it routinely is something else altogether. The principle reason why mCommerce is a spurious crock of nothingness is the fact that it is far easier for the MORI researchers to use a clipboard and pen and paper to record their answers than it is to use a mobile device (any mobile device).
And the mCommerce value chain is the most fragmented of all - with Nokia anxious to build as much value into its handsets as it can and nobody else in the value chain willing to cede any ground either.
Mobile commerce will be very simple- it will be visual commerce - people will take a picture and ask someone what they think of that item. Interactive Voice Response systems are about as sophisticated as it gets.
Mobile Lifestreams won’t be spending any time worrying about mCommerce. If you want to spend your time on it in these recessionary times, then the very best of luck to you- you are really going to need it. MCommerce is the biggest pile of hype the mobile industry has yet managed to invent- and that really is saying something after the WAP and location debacles. <<
- Eric - |
