09/05 23:28
Chartered Semi's Spending Plans Raise Investors' Ire (Update1)
By Greg Chang
Singapore, Sept. 6 (Bloomberg) -- Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. hasn't had much to brag about lately. Factories are working at less than half capacity, management has been replaced and it expects a loss of $87 million this quarter.
So why did the third-largest supplier of made-to-order chips ask shareholders this week for more money to build new plants? The answer, investors say: to keep pace with rivals such as Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. and United Microelectronics Corp., whose factories are humming.
``They have to run just to stay in third,'' said Henry Lee, a money manager at the Hendale Group Ltd., which manages about $80 million. Chartered Semiconductor must ``continually keep putting money in'' to maintain its business, he said.
Chartered Semiconductor shares its dilemma with other chipmakers. To stay on top, the biggest suppliers of made-to-order chips are investing billions of dollars on new plants to produce chips from silicon wafers measuring 300 millimeters or on equipment to etch ever-finer circuit features.
The Singapore-based company, 60 percent owned by Singapore Technologies Group, a government agency, plans to sell stock to its shareholders at a 52 percent discount to the Aug. 30 share price, the last trading day before the sale was announced.
Stock Tumbles
The company aims to raise $633 million for a new factory. Singapore Technologies agreed to invest $380 million.
The offering would bring to about $2.2 billion the amount that Chartered Semiconductor has raised since it first sold shares to the public in October 1999.
Chartered Semiconductor shares plunged 24 percent on Sept. 2, the day the sale was announced, bringing the stock's loss to 67 percent so far this year. The stock is vying with Datacraft Asia Ltd., which is being investigated for insider trading, to rank at the bottom of the Straits Times Index this year. The shares rose 2 cents to S$1.62 as of 10:27 a.m. local time today.
Singapore's stock exchange said it's investigating trading in Chartered Semiconductor shares after the stock fell 18 percent in the week before the company announced plans to raise money.
Investors and analysts are doubtful that money for new factories makes much sense right now. Chartered Semiconductor's spending on plants and equipment has exceeded operating cash flow for at least five years as it races to catch up with competitors.
``They're just constantly consuming cash,'' said Russell Tan, an analyst at NRA Capital's NetResearch Asia, who has rated Chartered Semiconductor ``sell'' since October. ``It's going to be really difficult, even with this large amount of money.''
The state of the chip industry isn't much help either. Chip sales dropped by a third last year to $155 billion, according to market researcher Dataquest Inc., making 2001 the worst year in the industry's 40-year history.
Wasted Opportunities?
This year doesn't look any better. The Semiconductor Industry Association expects chip sales to grow just 3 percent in 2002, it said this month.
Even analysts predicting a return to profitability for Chartered Semiconductor in 2004 may be optimistic, said Jeremy Whitley, an investment manager with Edinburgh Fund Managers, which manages about $400 million in Asia excluding Japan.
With cash of $831.4 million and an untapped credit line of $620 million, the company's decision to seek money now suggests it doesn't believe chip demand will pick up anytime soon, Tan said.
Keeping Pace
Even so, while sales have faltered, Chartered Semiconductor must keep investing in the latest chip-making equipment to keep pace with rivals, investors say.
``They're far too far behind,'' Whitley said. ``It's just a case of prolonging its life.''
Taiwan Semiconductor and United Microelectronics account for about 62 percent all custom-built chip sales, compared with 5 percent for Chartered Semiconductor, Gartner Inc. says.
Chartered Semiconductor must also cope with competition from new companies starting production in China. They include Grace Semiconductor Manufacturing Corp. and Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corp.
In the past, chip companies have slowed expansion to allow demand to catch up with supply. These days, more factories are being built even though a rebound in demand hasn't occurred, said Ho Hsiu Mei, a money manager with Citigroup Asset Management in Singapore. The result may be falling prices.
``Demand is not there and yet we are seeing new players come in,'' Ho said. ``It doesn't look good.''
Chartered Semiconductor's executive suites haven't been immune to chip-industry changes. Last month, Ang Kay Chai was named senior vice president, replacing John Docherty in the most recent of a string of new appointments. Since April, Chartered has changed its chief executive, chief financial officer and chairman and named two new senior vice presidents.
Chief Executive Chia Song Hwee says the company needs to use 70 percent of production capacity to break even, and 80 percent to generate $1 billion in cash to cover spending on factories and equipment. Chartered Semiconductor expects to use just 40 percent of its chip-making equipment this quarter.
``We are working towards the business situation where we can be self-sufficient,'' Chia said on a conference call this week with analysts. |
