We are humans. As such we have a role in the world that allows us to struggle
with issues of decency, honor, and the nobility of our human nature; while
simultaneously answering to issues of injustice, tragedy, and despotism.
This may be the point of our departing.
You seem, if I understand you correctly, to say that this role is mandatory. That it is our obligation, our responsibility, which we are not entitled to evade or avoid. Correct?
I would answer that it is an optional role we can take on or not if we choose. Now, if we choose not to, society does not have to admit us to its rights and benefits. But we have a right not to take on parts -- or all -- of that role as long as we are willing to accept the consequences.
Suicide is the ultimate decision to reject all of those roles Which is why I believe it is the right of any person. By denying the right to suicide, you seem to me necessarily to be denying a person's right to reject that role. You seem to be saying that the role is mandatory.
Which raises the question, how did this role come to be? And here we have to consider issues of the creation of man. If you believe that God created man, then you can legitimately claim (though you can't prove) that in creating man God laid that role on him, and that it is, like original sin, an original role that we have no right to reject.
If, on the other hand, you accept Darwinism, or if you accept the existence of one or more Gods but do not believe that they created man with this role as his necessary heritage, then where did the roles arise from? Did the dust which was created in the big bang have this role, and if so where did it come from? If not, it must have arisen somewhere along the path of evolution. How, and from what source? Is it entirely a human construct? If so, humans created it and humans can uncreate it. And in different societies of man it could have developed quite differently, so that this role might be that adopted by Western society, but a very different role might be (indeed, I would argue is) adopted by Eastern society, and a very different one by Bushman society, by Aboriginal society, by Native North American society, etc. Which means that if I simply move to one of those other places, if their role allows suicide, suddenly it's okay for me to commit my suicide. So in laying out your role creations you shouldn't say "we are humans" as though that settled the issue, but rather "we are humans who are in this particular one of the various constructs of human society and within this construct we have a role in our society (not the world, please) that mandates that we . . . " |
