I don't think GATA is very relevant to gold market anyway. But they are probably right about controlling the gold and silver market through derivatives. It's the highest volume market that controls price. Derivative market for gold and silver is the highest volume market, which, to some extent, is controlled by derivative MM. There are as many shorts in futures as there are longs. Always. So, what moves the price then?
Actually, I don't think gold stocks are controlled by derivatives. Derivative volume in gold stocks is very small compared to stock trading volume. But the broader stock market, currency market, and bond market are definitely controlled by derivatives. Normal relationships between stock, bond, and currency markets are screwed up due to derivative trading. For example, the dollar rises when bond drops, and vice versa. Why? As folks get long bonds, they hedge against the dollar drop, so they effectively short the dollar. When they sell bonds, they cover. Derivatives are a huge bomb, waiting to explode. Gold derivatives are a tiny portion of it, which, however, could become a fuse, should a physical metal squeeze materialize.
I honestly don't know what will happen to gold, should there be a collapse of the credit derivative bubble. This event will be extremely deflationary - the money supply will shrink enormously. So gold might as well drop sharply. |