PRESIDENT BUSH SPEAKS OUT ON OPENNESS, CLASSIFICATION
"We believe that the more we inform our American citizens, the better
our government will be," President Bush said Tuesday.
The remark could be considered conventional wisdom. Yet it is
unexpected from this President since by most objective measures --
such as the record number of classification decisions, skyrocketing
expenditures on classification-related activities, and growing
security controls on unclassified documents -- public access to
government information has been markedly curtailed under the Bush
Administration.
Nevertheless, the President reiterated, "We believe that the more
transparency there is in the system, the better the system functions
on behalf of the American people."
It follows that the less transparent aspects of government, such as
the national security decision making process, function less well,
which is manifestly true.
The President spoke at a signing ceremony for the Federal Funding
Accountability and Transparency Act, which will establish a
searchable online database of federal grants and contracts.
fas.org
A White House fact sheet presented an argument that the new law "Is
Part Of President Bush's Ongoing Commitment To Improve Transparency,
Accountability, And Management Across The Federal Government."
fas.org
At another event on Tuesday, the President appeared to express doubt
that the national security classification system was working
properly.
Referring to press reports in the New York Times and elsewhere about
a classified National Intelligence Estimate on trends in terrorism,
portions of which were declassified Tuesday, President Bush
complained that "Somebody has taken it upon themselves to leak
classified information for political purposes."
In Washington, he said, "there's no such thing as classification
anymore, hardly."
fas.org
In reality, of course, classification has expanded in size and scope
to unprecedented levels in the Bush Administration.
So the President might have been making a deep point that the
efficacy of classification declines when its use increases sharply,
along the lines of Justice Potter Stewart's familiar dictum that
"when everything is classified, then nothing is classified." Or
maybe he just misspoke.... |
