Hi Wharf Rat; I think the paper is junk but your comment is, as is usual for you, quite incorrect: "Of course not. No peer pub cites them, either. They were flushed down the toilet, long ago."
First, they were published in a peer reviewed journal, and second, a comment on their paper claiming it was wrong was published in the same journal. Here's the comment article:
COMMENT ON "FALSIFICATION OF THE ATMOSPHERIC CO2 GREENHOUSE EFFECTS WITHIN THE FRAME OF PHYSICS"
Halpern, Colose, Ho-stuart, Shore, Smith and Zimmerman, IJMPB 24, 10 (2010)
In this journal, Gerhard Gerlich and Ralf D. Tscheuschner claim to have falsified the existence of an atmospheric greenhouse effect.1 Here, we show that their methods, logic, and conclusions are in error. ...
worldscientific.com
I mean really. Do you bother to check any of the "facts" you bring to us?
-- Carl |
