The COVID Culture War Will Never End
Pandemics end; culture wars are forever.
Jonathan V. Last
1. The COVID Culture War
Donald Trump responded to the pandemic by turning COVID into a culture war. He demonized mitigation efforts, peddled a constant stream of misinformation (which created an alternate reality for his followers), and used his office to literally spread the virus itself.
As a result, we are creeping up on 600,000 confirmed deaths. The real total, once we do a full forensic accounting, will eventually be revealed to be much higher.
And even though Trump is out of office, the culture war he waged continues. Here is a story that 100 percent does not happen if Trump had behaved like responsible human being:
A fifth-grade math and science teacher peddled a bogus conspiracy theory on Wednesday to students at Centner Academy, a private school in Miami, warning them that they should not hug parents who had been vaccinated against the coronavirus for more than five seconds because they might be exposed to harmful vaccine shedding. . . .
Nearly a week before, the school had threatened teachers’ employment if they got a coronavirus vaccine before the end of the school year.
That’s right: A school is forbidding teachers from getting vaccinated.
[V]accinated teachers would have to stay away from students, or would not be allowed to return for now if they get the vaccine over the summer. “If you want to get it, this is not going to be the right school for you,” Ms. Centner told teachers about the vaccine on a virtual call.
How did this happen? Why would a school do something this insane?
Centner Academy opened in its current form last year, after the Centners, who previously owned just the preschool, took over the Metropolitan International School, an established private school that focused on foreign languages and served an international clientele. Its owner retired and said the school would merge with the preschool owned by the Centners, who have donated heavily in recent years to the Republican Party and former President Donald J. Trump.
Oh.
I know what you’re thinking: How is this legal? Doesn’t employment law prohibit employers from discriminating against workers on the basis of their private health care decisions?
Could a school fire a teacher for taking the birth control pill?
Could a school tell a teacher with cancer that if she takes chemo drugs, she can’t return to work?
Could a school tell a teacher with a severe allergy that he’s not allowed to carry an EpiPen?
I dunno. I’m not a lawyer. But the local pols in Florida tried to avoid having this litigated in the courts by simply passing a law preventing schools from telling teachers they can’t get vaccinated.
And that bill failed.
Why? Because for the Republicans in Florida, the bill wasn’t about vaccines or public health or employment discrimination. It was about the culture war. And they knew which side they were on.
2. Both Sides
Which brings us to Brookline.
Massachusetts has relaxed its guidelines on outdoor mask usage. The policy is now that so long as you can keep some distance between people, then you don’t need to wear a mask outdoors.
This is a sensible, but still cautious, guide. For people who are not vaccinated, if they’re going to be outdoors in a packed space, they should wear masks. And since there’s no way to tell the goats from the sheep, it’s not crazy to say that if you’re in a crowded outdoor space, everyone should wear masks.
Brookline—think of it as East Coast Berkeley—has decided that they’re going to keep the outdoor mask mandate in place for everyone, at least for a little while longer.
I want to say this part out loud: I’m not saying that COVID Academy and Brookline are equivalent. What the Florida school is doing is dangerous. What Brookline is doing is silly and inconvenient. Many more Republicans than Democrats are invested in these fights. Republicans are the ones who started this politicization. Both sides are not equal.
But both impulses are fruit of the same tree: the transformation of COVID into culture war. Masks and vaccines aren’t talismans. They’re tools. They never should have been imbued with political significance in the first place.
How do we leach this poison out of our system? I wish I knew. The only thing to do is slowly and surely push against it. Though, to be honest, I’m not sure that’ll work.
Culture wars are easy to start, but nigh on impossible to end.
thetriad.thebulwark.com |
