China hits back at EV tariffs with European dairy probe
Beijing escalates trade dispute after Brussels unveils additional levies on vehicles
China accounted for about 9.5% of total European dairy exports last year
Edward White and Thomas Hale in Shanghai and Alice Hancock in Brussels
China has launched an anti-dumping investigation into imported European dairy products, in the latest escalation of a trade dispute with the EU.
The investigation comes a day after the European Commission published a series of additional levies on Chinese electric vehicle imports, despite opposition from Beijing.
The Chinese commerce ministry said on Wednesday that its probe into EU dairy imports was prompted by complaints from domestic manufacturers over European subsidies. According to a statement, the investigation will cover “certain products” including creams and cheeses.
The move marked Beijing’s strongest retaliation yet against Brussels’ EV tariffs. China has already opened anti-dumping probes into French cognac and EU pork imports and has lodged a complaint at the World Trade Organization.
The bloc’s chief diplomat, Josep Borrell, said at an event in Spain this week that the EU “must not be naive” but that a trade war was “maybe?.?.?.?unavoidable”.
The European Commission said Brussels “takes note” of China’s decision to launch an anti-subsidy probe into certain dairy products and would analyse the procedure “very closely”.
“The commission will firmly defend the interests of the EU dairy industry?.?.?.?and intervene as appropriate to ensure that the investigation fully complies with relevant WTO rules,” it said.
The EU’s Chamber of Commerce in China said Beijing’s action “should not be considered a surprise”.
“Regrettably, the use of trade defence instruments by one government is increasingly being responded to seemingly in kind by the recipient government,” the chamber said, adding that it hoped the investigation would “be conducted fairly and transparently”.
The EU’s biggest subsidy programme is the €60bn-a-year Common Agricultural Policy, which consumes roughly a third of the bloc’s budget.
Alexander Anton, secretary-general of the European Dairy Association, said he was “confident” that the CAP was compliant with WTO rules and that the EU and China “will find a constructive way to resolve any bilateral disputes”.
“Vive l’Europe et vive le lait,” he added.
Patrick Pagani, deputy secretary-general of the EU’s biggest farming body Copa Cogeca, said farmers had “feared this further escalation in the EU-Chinese trade relationship and the continuous impact on our sector”.
“Again we see our well-performing exports being the target due to other disputes,” he said, adding that the “most worrying” aspect was the challenge to the CAP, which he described as “unjustified”.
European dairy exports to China were valued at about €1.8bn last year, down from €2bn a year earlier, according to European Commission trade data, and accounted for about 9.5 per cent of the EU’s total dairy exports.
The Chinese dairy industry bodies claimed that imported EU dairy products had benefited from a total of 20 subsidy programmes. Germany is the bloc’s largest producer of milk, butter and cheese, followed by France. The
Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association warned that the measures could be a “savage blow” at a time when dairy farmers are reeling from low prices, poor weather and years of higher input costs. Ireland exports dairy goods worth €450mn a year to China.
“If the EU is going to embark on a trade dispute that wipes out our [milk] powder and butter trade with China, then ICMSA will be demanding that the EU compensate the farmers,” said the group’s president Denis Drennan.
The market share of imports in China’s infant formula market, where competition has increased and regulations have been tightened, fell from 51 per cent in 2019 to 44 per cent in 2023, according to Dutch bank Rabobank. Recommended Global InsightAndy Bounds The EU has a chicken feet problem with China
China’s declining birth rate has also forced domestic and foreign companies to push into new products in the country, such as those targeting older consumers.
Imports of milk powder and fluid milk have also fallen this year because of higher domestic production, according to estimates from the US Department of Agriculture in May.
“Growth in raw milk production continues to outpace consumption, creating an oversupply in the Chinese market,” the report said.
Additional reporting by Gloria Li in Hong Kong and Wang Xueqiao in Shanghai |
