After 7 Decades of Measurements From a Peak in Hawaii, Trump’s Budget Would End Them
Closing Mauna Loa and three other U.S. sites that track greenhouse gases would disrupt a decades-long record of the planet’s changing atmosphere.
Listen to this article · 6:30 min Learn more
The Mauna Loa Observatory, on the top of Hawaii Island, is one of the world’s best places for measuring greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.Credit...Erin Schaff/The New York Times
By Rebecca Dzombak
July 17, 2025, 12:48 p.m. ET
More than 11,100 feet above sea level, surrounded by nothing but black rocks, white clouds and blue sky, the Mauna Loa Observatory is in a Goldilocks spot for studying the atmosphere.
The air that swirls around the isolated outpost located on a Hawaiian volcano is a mix from all over the Northern Hemisphere. That makes it one of the best places to measure greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. It is indispensable to scientists around the world.
The readings collected from Mauna Loa, starting in 1958, were used to create what is famously known as the Keeling curve. It’s an upward-swooping line that charts the steady rise of carbon dioxide over the past seven decades — the result of nations burning oil, gas and coal.
But President Trump’s proposed 2026 budget would put an end to Mauna Loa, along with three other key observatories and almost all the climate research being done by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
Trump Seeks to Cut Basic Scientific Research by Roughly One-Third, Report Shows
July 10, 2025
“It’s frankly inconceivable,” said Lisa Graumlich, an emeritus climate scientist at the University of Washington and past president of the American Geophysical Union. People know and understand the “iconic” record, she said. “A lot of the science we do is incredibly complex, and this record is something that can be grasped.”
The observatory is part of a global network of stations that monitor the atmosphere. The research performed at these labs lets scientists assess changes over the long term, figure out what caused the changes and make better predictions for extreme events like heat waves, droughts and floods. And the stations can help scientists tell which climate policies are working, which are not, and if global warming is accelerating.
“Why, for relatively little cost, would we want to lose that ability?” Dr. Graumlich said.
Lisa Graumlich, former president of the American Geophysical Union, at a meeting of the organization in 2024.Credit...Anastasia Rodopoulou/IISD/ENB
Consistency in collecting these climate records is key. “It’s not unlike going to the doctor,” said Rick Spinrad, who was the administrator of NOAA during the Biden administration. “You go regularly, you get your blood work done, and if there are any changes, you can catch them early.”
The same is true for planetary checkups, he said, and that’s what Mauna Loa provides. The average concentration of carbon dioxide, one of the main causes of climate change, has risen rapidly, throwing the planet’s natural systems out of balance. Mauna Loa’s records show it has climbed from 316 parts per million to more than 430 parts per million.
Dr. Graumlich has studied climate change since the 1970s, when, she recalled, scientists questioned whether humans were really capable of changing Earth’s climate. The data from Mauna Loa answered that question.
“It became so clear that we were moving beyond natural variability, and that fossil fuel burning was causing it,” Dr. Graumlich said. “It took decades for us to realize that.”
As important as the Mauna Loa Observatory is, it doesn’t work in isolation. To have a reliable and global picture of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, scientists need to collect samples from multiple places. NOAA operates three other monitoring stations — one in Alaska, one in American Samoa and one at the geographic South Pole — to compile its global average carbon dioxide trend.
The president’s budget would close all four stations, eliminating the United States’ pole-to-pole view of greenhouse gases. They cannot easily be replaced.
“We’d lose large areas of observation and make it harder to understand where greenhouse gases are coming from, and where they’re going,” Dr. Spinrad said.
Ralph Keeling, son of Charles Keeling, with a chart of the eponymous curve at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in San Diego earlier this year.Credit...Patrick T. Fallon/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
NOAA declined a request to comment for this article, saying that the agency does not comment on the budget.
But the cuts are in line with the Trump administration’s dismissal of the risks of global warming and end federal efforts to reduce the emissions that are heating the planet.
NOAA also runs a “flask network” that collects air samples from all around the world, including remote places that lack the infrastructure to take measurements. These are processed at NOAA’s Global Monitoring Lab in Boulder, Colo., which would also fall under the budget ax. Other such networks of air sampling exist, but they lack the coverage that NOAA’s provides, said Ralph Keeling, a professor of climate science at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography and the son of Charles Keeling, who started the Mauna Loa carbon dioxide curve.
“We would lose any understanding of how climate is changing, at what pace, and where,” Dr. Spinrad said. Identifying what places are most vulnerable to climate change would be more difficult, as would pinpointing promising spots for carbon dioxide removal efforts and assessing those efforts, he said.
Although other countries and scientific organizations are measuring greenhouse gases and the atmosphere, both through air sampling networks and dedicated measurement labs, NOAA’s observatories and programs are internationally invaluable.
An atmospheric technician carried a briefcase of atmospheric monitoring equipment at the Mauna Loa Observatory during a period in 2023 when the observatory was out of power from a volcanic eruption.Credit...Erin Schaff/The New York Times
Scientists at Mauna Loa and other observatories also track methane, a greenhouse gas that’s much more potent in the short term than carbon dioxide, as well as nitrous oxide, aerosols and ozone-depleting substances. They monitor for soot and other particulate pollution in the air and observe changes in solar radiation, weather and wind patterns.
Failing to track those metrics could have broad implications.
“It’s not just the climate mission that gets compromised,” Dr. Spinrad said. “It’s the ability to protect people and property for things like wildfire. So much is lost with the elimination and termination of these labs.”
Abandoning Mauna Loa would be yet another clear signal to the world that the United States is no longer serious about climate change, scientists said.
“The NOAA effort is really the backbone of the global effort to track greenhouse gases,” Dr. Keeling said. Scientists building other long-term records rely on the Keeling curve to interpret their own. “We need to do everything we can do make sure these stations don’t close.”
Cuts to NOAA’s climate research
Recipients of a U.S. Climate Science Fellowship Are Put on Unpaid Leave
July 9, 2025
White House Plan Calls for NOAA Research Programs to Be Dismantled
April 11, 2025
See more on: U.S. Politics
The Latest on the Trump Administration- Trump’s Cane Sugar Plan: After President Trump announced that Coke will be made with cane sugar in the U.S., as it is in Mexico, foodies of Mexican heritage said they weren’t excited.
- Can Trump Fire Powell?: The Trump administration is toying with removing Jerome Powell as chair of the Federal Reserve, a legally knotty endeavor. Trump wants lower rates, but firing Powell could have the opposite effect. Few Americans have confidence in the chairman to do the right thing on the economy, though attitudes are deeply partisan.
- Spurned U.S. Attorney Clings to Job: District judges recently denied John Sarcone, who was interim U.S. attorney, the permanent position. The Justice Department then gave him a special appointment so he could continue in the role.
- Emil Bove III: More than 900 former Justice Department lawyers signed a letter to the Senate Judiciary Committee expressing “deep concern” about Bove’s nomination, a senior Justice Department official, to serve as a federal appeals judge. The committee unanimously voted to advance his nomination after Democrats stormed out in protest.
- FEMA Funding Lawsuit: A coalition of 20 states sued the Trump administration over its decision to shut down a multibillion-dollar grant program aimed at protecting communities from floods, hurricanes and other natural disasters.
- Health Department Shake-Up: Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., the health secretary, ousted his chief of staff and a deputy chief of staff, both of whom were seen as practical and effective government veterans.
- The Quiet Winners in Trump’s Big Bill: The president’s marquee policy legislation is best known for slashing taxes and cutting social safety net programs. But the sweeping measure also included many little-noticed goodies and add-ons.
- Jeffrey Epstein Case: A leading Republican critic of Trump has begun an effort to force a vote on releasing files related to Epstein’s case, and Maurene Comey, a federal prosecutor who worked on the Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell criminal cases, was abruptly fired, according to six people with knowledge of the matter. Trump said his supporters’ outrage was just the latest “scam” cooked up by Democrats.
How We Report on the Trump Administration
Hundreds of readers asked about our coverage of the president. Times editors and reporters responded to some of the most common questions
nytimes.com |
