SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : View from the Center and Left Middle East Annex

 Public ReplyPrvt ReplyMark as Last ReadFilePrevious 10Next 10PreviousNext  
To: S. maltophilia who wrote (3018)9/24/2025 9:19:01 PM
From: Madharry1 Recommendation

Recommended By
S. maltophilia

  Read Replies (1) of 3123
 
How soon we forget-

Overview of Iraqi Civilian Deaths from the US-Led Invasion Estimating the number of Iraqi civilian deaths resulting from the 2003 US-led invasion and subsequent occupation is challenging due to the chaotic environment, varying methodologies, and political sensitivities. No single figure is universally accepted, as counts differ based on whether they track only direct violent deaths (e.g., from combat or bombings) or indirect excess deaths (e.g., from destroyed infrastructure, disease, or malnutrition). Most estimates focus on the period from March 2003 (invasion start) to 2011 (US withdrawal), though violence continued afterward.

Key challenges include:

  • Underreporting: Many deaths in remote areas or during peak sectarian violence (2006–2007) went unrecorded.
  • Scope: "From the US invasion" can mean deaths directly caused by coalition forces (e.g., airstrikes) or all war-related civilian fatalities (including insurgent attacks, sectarian killings, and indirect effects).
  • Sources: Media-based tallies (e.g., Iraq Body Count) are conservative, while household surveys (e.g., Lancet studies) extrapolate broader impacts.
Major Estimates Below is a table summarizing prominent estimates from credible sources, focusing on civilians where specified. These represent a range of methodologies: media reports, household surveys, and academic compilations.



SourceTime PeriodEstimated Civilian DeathsNotes/Methodology
Iraq Body Count (IBC)March 2003–October 2024186,901–210,296 (violent deaths)Media-reported violent civilian deaths only (e.g., from coalition actions, insurgents, or crime). Conservative; excludes indirect deaths. Coalition forces responsible for ~15–20% (e.g., ~28,000–42,000).
Costs of War Project (Brown University)March 2003–August 2021~200,000–315,000 (direct war violence)Includes direct violent deaths from all parties; part of broader post-9/11 wars tally (940,000+ total direct deaths across regions). Indirect deaths add 3.6–3.8 million across all post-9/11 wars.
Lancet Study (2004)March 2003–September 2004~98,000 (excess deaths; ~80% violent)Household cluster survey of 33 clusters; majority civilians. Air strikes by coalition forces caused most violent deaths.
Lancet Study (2006)March 2003–July 2006~601,000 (violent deaths out of 655,000 excess)Larger household survey (1,849 households); 92% of excess deaths violent, mostly civilians. Gunfire and bombings primary causes.
PLOS Medicine Study (2013)March 2003–June 2011~405,000–461,000 (excess deaths; ~60% violent)Household survey of 2,000 households; includes indirect deaths from infrastructure collapse. Adjusted for emigration.
Opinion Research Business (ORB) Poll (2007, extrapolated)March 2003–2018~1–2.4 million (total deaths)UK poll-based estimate, extrapolated using IBC data; includes civilians and indirect effects. Higher-end figures from Just Foreign Policy analysis.

Breakdown by Cause and Phase
  • Invasion Phase (March–April 2003): ~3,750–7,500 civilian deaths, mostly from coalition airstrikes and ground operations. IBC recorded ~6,700, averaging 318/day.
  • Occupation and Insurgency (2003–2011): Peak violence in 2006–2007 (~25,000–30,000 civilian deaths/year). Insurgents/sectarian groups caused ~60–70% of violent deaths; coalition ~15–20%; unknown/criminal ~20%.
  • Direct vs. Indirect: Direct violent deaths (e.g., bombings, gunfire) are ~200,000–600,000. Indirect excess deaths (e.g., from collapsed healthcare) push totals to 400,000–1 million+ by 2011. Post-2011 ISIS conflict added ~50,000–100,000 more.
  • Demographics: Women and children comprised ~30–40% of civilian deaths; children were disproportionately killed in suicide bombings.
Key Insights
  • Conservative Range: 200,000–300,000 direct civilian deaths (IBC and Costs of War), substantiated by media verification and military logs (e.g., WikiLeaks added 15,000 previously unlisted deaths).
  • Higher Estimates: 400,000–600,000+ excess deaths (surveys like Lancet/PLOS), supported by statistical sampling and consistency with UN data (e.g., 2004 UNDP survey: 18,000–29,000).
  • Ongoing Impact: As of 2025, violence persists at low levels (~1,000–2,000 civilian deaths/year), and indirect effects (e.g., displacement of 4+ million) continue.
These figures highlight the invasion's catastrophic human cost, far exceeding pre-war expectations. For deeper dives, consult IBC's database or Costs of War reports.
Report TOU ViolationShare This Post
 Public ReplyPrvt ReplyMark as Last ReadFilePrevious 10Next 10PreviousNext