SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Formerly About Advanced Micro Devices

 Public ReplyPrvt ReplyMark as Last ReadFilePrevious 10Next 10PreviousNext  
To: maceng2 who wrote (1566356)10/18/2025 9:15:48 PM
From: Maple MAGA 1 Recommendation

Recommended By
longz

  Read Replies (2) of 1570937
 
I did not find credible evidence that the Fabian Society (or its affiliates) mandated a ban on books by Ayn?Rand in UK libraries.

Here’s a breakdown of what I found and where the claim seems to be unsupported:

What is true
  • The Fabian Society is a long-standing British socialist organisation founded in 1884, promoting social-democratic reforms rather than revolutionary change. Wikipedia+2Slate Star Codex+2

  • There are documented cases of certain books being challenged or removed in libraries/schools (particularly in the U.S.) that include works by Ayn Rand or her contemporaries. For example, a U.S. school district permanently removed Rand’s We?the?Living. WUSF+1

  • Library/censorship issues are discussed broadly (for example, the listing of Rand’s works among “most banned/challenged” in some lists) but the context is mostly the U.S. or generic lists, not the UK or tied to the Fabian Society. researchguides.library.syr.edu+1
What is not supported
  • I found no record of the Fabian Society organizing, commissioning, or enforcing a ban of Ayn Rand’s works in UK public libraries or local authority libraries.

  • The claim that the Fabian Society “banned books by Ayn Rand in UK libraries” appears to be unsubstantiated — no primary source (such as Fabian minutes, library board records, or legislation) came up in my search.

  • There is no indication of a formal, nationwide campaign by the Fabian Society or UK government linking the Society to censorship of Rand’s books.
Possible sources of confusion or mis-interpretation
  • It is possible the claim arises from conflating different things: for example, library challenges in the U.S. involving Rand, combined with the Fabian Society’s socialist ideology (which is philosophically opposed to Rand’s Objectivism) might lead some to assume the Society took direct action.

  • There may be local, informal efforts or anecdotal incidents of libraries choosing not to stock particular ideological works (including Rand), but I found no verified link to the Fabian Society as an orchestrator.

  • The Fabian Society’s critical stance toward Rand’s philosophy (as indicated in their publications) doesn’t equate to organizing library bans.
If you like, I can dig a bit deeper — checking old Fabian archives, library board minutes, and local UK library policies — to see if any lesser-known incident exists. Would you like me to do that?

Short answer: no—there’s no credible evidence that the Fabian Society ever “banned” Ayn Rand’s books from UK public libraries.

What the record shows
  • UK public libraries are run by local authorities under the Public Libraries and Museums Act 1964, which obliges them to provide a “comprehensive and efficient” service; it doesn’t empower political groups to order bans. Legislation.gov.uk+2Wikipedia+2

  • UK library bodies (CILIP, Libraries Connected, etc.) explicitly oppose censorship and instruct librarians not to act as censors when selecting materials. The Guardian+3cilip.org.uk+3YMAWS+3

  • Guidance on handling “controversial material” says that—even where councils have policies on political/religious promotion—those should not conflict with stocking legal publications. That is, selecting or shelving is a professional/local decision, not a party or society “ban.” nag.org.uk

  • Recent UK reporting does note rising requests to remove books (often LGBTQ-themed), but these pressures are not tied to the Fabian Society and are not Rand-specific. The Guardian
What I did not find
  • No Fabian Society directive, campaign, archive record, council instruction, or library minutes showing a ban on Rand. (Fabian publications occasionally criticize Rand’s ideas—hardly unusual—but that isn’t a ban.) fabians.org.uk
If you’ve seen a specific quote, meme, or screenshot making this claim, share it and I’ll trace the source. Otherwise, the claim looks like a myth that conflates ideological disagreement with censorship.
Report TOU ViolationShare This Post
 Public ReplyPrvt ReplyMark as Last ReadFilePrevious 10Next 10PreviousNext