Lehman's report y'all...
08:34am EDT 12-Jun-98 Lehman Brothers ( M. A. Gumport, CFA 1(212)526-536) CUBE C-Cube Microsystems: 19% Drop Looks Like an Opportunity, But...
Ticker : CUBE Rank(Prev): 2-Outperform Rank(Curr): 2-Outperform Price : $15.69 52wk Range: $35.00-15.69 Price Target: $27 Today's Date : 06/12/98 Fiscal Year : DEC ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EPS 1997 1998 1999 2000 QTR. Actual Prev. Curr. Prev. Curr. Prev. Curr. 1st: 0.40A 0.27A 0.27A 0.30E 0.30E 0.40E 0.40E 2nd: 0.21A 0.21E 0.21E 0.30E 0.30E 0.40E 0.40E 3rd: 0.25A 0.27E 0.27E 0.39E 0.39E 0.44E 0.44E 4th: 0.30A 0.35E 0.35E 0.46E 0.46E 0.51E 0.51E ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Year:$ 1.15A $ 1.10E $ 1.10E $ 1.45E $ 1.45E $ 1.75E $ 1.75E Street Est.: $ 1.09E $ 1.15E $ 1.35E $ 1.43E $ -.--E $ -.--E ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revenue (1998E): 374.1 Mil. Return On Equity*(97): 14.2 % Proj. 3yr EPS Grth: 20.0 % Shares Outstanding*: 41.1 Mil. Dividend Yield: N/A Mkt Capitalization*: 644.8 Mil. P/E 1998; 1999 : 14.3 X; 10.8 X Current Book Value*:$6.71/sh; 2.3X Convertible: YES Debt-to-Capital*: 0.3 % Disclosure(s): C, A
* Includes convertibles in equity ($86.3 mil.) and shares outstanding. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
** CUBE PLUNGES 19% ON ABSENCE OF NEWS. DISCUSSIONS WITH MANAGEMENT SUGGEST OUR ESTIMATES ARE CONSERVATIVE. EXPECT 2Q98 GROSS MARGIN OF AT LEAST 53%
** MOST LIKELY THE DROP REFLECTS FEARS OF A CHINA DEVALUATION (50% OF CUBE'S SALES ARE FROM CHINA). CUBE LIKELY WOULD WEATHER THAT RELATIVELY WELL.
** TIMING NOT GOOD. CHIP STOCKS IN GENERAL IN RETREAT DUE TO SOFT BUSINESS CONDITIONS AND UPCOMING NEGATIVE SEASONALS. SO WE ARE HESITANT TO LEAP IN DESPITE WHAT APPEARS TO BE A VERY ATTRACTIVE OPPORTUNITY UNTIL WE UNDERSTAND BETTER THE MOTIVATION OF THE SELLER. THERE IS PROBABLY TIME TO THOROUGHLY REVIEW ALL ISSUES. MORE NEWS AFTER FURTHER REVIEW WITH MANAGEMENT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CUBE PLUNGES 18.5% ON ABSENCE OF NEWS. A quick check with management reconfirmed the trends we noted last week: Our $0.21 2Q98 EPS estimate on sales of $83 mil. appears slightly conservative. VCD (video CD; 48% of 1997 sales) sales into China will be seasonally down but remain relatively robust, and a relatively modest seasonal pickup in dollar volume remains a reasonable expectation over the next 6 months. We continue to expect CUBE's 1998 VCD sales down 10%. Divicom (33% of 1997 sales) appears headed for close to 30% growth on the strength of demand for its TV broadcast digital encoding equipment. Opportunities for upside in digital settop boxes (8% of sales) and particularly in DVD (2%) remain on track. Two key business wins (Divicom, principally a supplier to Echostar, is expected to win some DirecTV business, and CUBE's partnership with Matsushita/Panasonic position CUBE for better settop box sales) have not occurred, but we believe these opportunities, particularly with DirecTV, remain good.
COULD IT BE FEARS OF A CHINA DEVALUATION? Talk is up in recent days of the risk of a devaluation in China. We think there is some chance investors are racing away from CUBE because of this risk since nearly 50% of CUBE's sales come from China. However, CUBE's transactions are all dollar based, the cost of CUBE's chip is a small percentage of the end selling price of a VCD, and CUBE has been adjusting reasonably well to nearly 50% annual price reductions.
If a China devaluation is the problem, we think CUBE will weather it well.
OR IS IT SOMETHING ELSE? Endless rumors circulate on the collapse of the VCD business. Far more damaging would be the loss by Divicom of key Echostar business. Our understanding remains that the VCD opportunity is gradually declining, and Divicom's relationship with Echostar is firm.
WE THINK THE STEEP DROP IS A MAJOR OPPORTUNITY, BUT.The timing is unattractive and our conviction is not 100%. The chip industry itself clearly is now looking at a 5% 2Q98 decline and facing the normal negative summer seasonals.
Clearly, there is a heavily motivated seller in the market. Until a better understanding on the motivation of the seller emerges, a thorough reappraisal of CUBE's growth and profit opportunities is required. MORE NEWS AFTER FURTHER DISCUSSIONS WITH MANAGEMENT.
IN SUM, WE ARE HESITANT ON THE TIMING BUT LIKE THE VALUE. We continue to feel that high gross margin is one of the key attractions of any chip maker during the current period of poor demand, and CUBE's 2Q98 should at least match or exceed the 53% it achieved in 1Q98. Given that we also believe CUBE has a high probability of showing sales acceleration by 3Q98 based on the strength of Divicom in digital broadcasting, normal VCD seasonality, and start up of more meaningful DVD and STB volumes, CUBE story becomes more compelling.
Finally, we believe long term CUBE is positioned at the heart of the most dynamic portion of the chip market, digital video, and will enjoy strong long term growth and profitability. The good news about the tough current chip market conditions is that there is probably time to thoroughly reevaluate the risks in the CUBE story before stepping in.
BUSINESS DESCRIPTION: Leader in compression technology, the key enabler for the emerging boom in digital video. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclosure Legend: A-Lehman Brothers Inc. managed or co-managed within the past three years a public offering of securities for this company. B-An employee of Lehman Brothers Inc. is a director of this company. C-Lehman Brothers Inc. makes a market in the securities of this company. G-The Lehman Brothers analyst who covers this company also has position in its securities. First Call Corporation - all rights reserved.
|