One interesting possibility would be to have vouchers worth approximately the cost of a public education, but not allow voucher-accepting schools to charge anything but what they get from the voucher. That way we wouldn't be subsidizing those who want and can afford a much more expensive education, but would allow for the possibility that private schools could provide a better education at the same cost.
I'm not sure where I stand on this issue, though. I know, fairly directly, of a case in which a kid was having nightmares because of the stuff he was being told in a Christian preschool (burning in hell, etc..); when the parents took him out of that school because of that and other concerns about the quality of the education, the school sicced the child-abuse authorities on the parents. (Not saying this is typical of Christian schools, of course.) I could imagine that a rapid proliferation of private schools could increase the incidence of such stuff.
I wouldn't be surprised if some kids have to suffer in pretty low-grade schools either because their parents just don't care, or because they put some hardcore version of religion ahead of a decent education. Probably not too prevalent, but I'd guess it would happen. There would be standards, of course, but they could be hard to enforce. |