<<"What is my opinion of the article by Israel Shahak? Well, first, I did a little digging, and quickly discovered that Shahak is promoted by Idaho white separatist Michael Hoffman"
You are such a profound thinker, Christine. You are now ready for the second grade and we have not even reached mid-term.>>
Now, now, Emile, I think it is possible to disagree with someone and stay polite and not just stoop to the level of insults. How do you define 'profound thinker', anyway? Would that include someone like you, a Christian white separatist and Jew hater who worships a dark brown skinned Jew for a savior? You don't see any contradictions there? Have you thought about that? I am profoundly puzzled at your logical leap. How do you think Jesus feels about the Holocaust? As a Jew, do you think he would really want someone worshiping him who denies that all those millions of Jews died? I wonder how he would even feel to find that his Christian followers persecuted the Jews. I think he would be very, very unhappy.
<<Because Mr. Kauffman of the white separatist quoted Mr. Shahak aritcle, his opinions and scholarship are forever discredited? Does that mean that evertime someone quotes the Jewish Zionist newspapers such as the NY Times, Washington Post, WSJ, etc. they becomes advocates of Zionism? Does it mean that everytime someone quotes someone else that the philosophy and ideology of the quoter become the ideology and philosophy of the quotee? You are definitely breaking
new ground in intellectual scholarship. I think I get your point.>>
Well, I'm sure you were being condescending and sarcastic when you wrote this, but really it is you who is breaking new ground in intellectual scholarship if you seriously believe that because these papers may be Zionist, they cannot report on many subjects objectively. I don't read their coverage of Jewish events and news. There are many more objective European and Middle Eastern newspapers, many of them on the web, to get a balanced view. There are also web sources for Israeli human rights organizations that report the atrocities against the Palestinians. But you are throwing away the dreidel with the gift wrappings or something discounting those entirely, in every way, and instead turning to white supremacist organizations which deny that the Holocaust happened for your political views. The Zionist press is certainly more objective than that! |
