07:33am EST 27-Jan-99 Bear Stearns (Ehrens,Scott 212/272-9382) AMZN AMZN: Reports Terrific Fourth Quarter:ROIC Is Key (Not Gross Margin)(Part 2 / 2
(Part 2 / 2) Outstanding Quarterly Results
Amazon.com had pre-released revenue numbers earlier this month so while the total figure was not in doubt, the revenue segmentation provided additional positive results. Total revenue reached $252.8 million in the fourth quarter, up by a whopping 65% sequentially and by 313% year over year, well ahead of our estimate of $185 million. International sales accounted for 19% of total revenues or $48 million, fueled by the expansion of Amazon.com into Germany (amazon.de) and the U.K. (amazon.co.uk). For the first time consumers in these two countries have access to local Amazon branded web sites and are now serviced from distribution centers within their own borders. Although building off small numbers, the two new local editions increased their revenues nearly 4x over the combined third quarter sales, establishing both as the number one online booksellers in their respective countries. Additionally, Amazon.com noted that music sales represented $33.1 million, an increase of 130% over third quarter sales. Revenues from all new expansion areas which have been in operation for only a few months (music, video, Germany, and U.K.) accounted for 25% of total revenues, highlighting the increasing diversity among the company's revenue sources.
Gross margins decreased to 21.1%, down from 22.7% last quarter, due to several reasons. While some may pint to this statistic as an indication of weakness in the business model, we believe otherwise and would point to our ROIC analysis. Amazon.com explained the sequential decline by noting the shift in product mix from higher margin books to lower margin music, video, and European sales. The company also noted that holiday shoppers purchased more hard-covers which carry deeper discounts than soft- cover counterparts. Gift certificates for product delays and aggressive pricing in the video sector also contributed to the gross margin decline.
Amazon.com made significant improvement in operating expenses which fell as a percentage of sales to 28.2% from 36.2% in the third quarter. Marketing & Sales expense was roughly $2 million higher than we had anticipated and accounted for 19.2% of sales, down from 24.4.% last quarter, marking the first time this number has been below the 20% level. Included in Marketing & Sales expense are fulfillment costs, customer service and advertising. The company stated that the increase in marketing and sales was mostly due to increases in fulfillment costs. Therefore we estimate that fulfillment and customer service increased to $27.8 million or 11.0% of revenues. This implies advertising expense of $20 million, or 8% of sales, which means that the average cost to acquire a new customer declined by 15% to $12.17 from $14.34 in the third quarter.
Product and Development expense was $17.3 million, about $2.3 higher than our estimate due to new technological initiatives and investments. However as a percent of sales, product development expense fell to 6.8%, down from 130 basis points from both the third quarter and our estimate. General & Administrative expense was almost $0.5 million ahead of our estimate, at $5.5 million, and was 2.2.% of sales, down from 3.2% of sales last quarter and below our 2.8% estimate. Amazon.com achieved this low level despite the added costs of overtime and temporary workers to fulfill the abundance of orders during the holiday season. On a pro forma basis (i.e. before the effect of goodwill associated with recent acquisitions) Amazon.com lost $17.8 million on the operating line. The operating loss represented 7.0% of sales, narrower than last quarter's 13.7% loss, and narrower than our estimate of a 13.3% loss.
EPS and Balance Sheet Looking Good
On a pro-forma basis Amazon.com had an EPS of $(0.14), beating our estimate of a loss of $(0.19) per share and First Call consensus of ($0.18) per share. On a GAAP basis including $24.3 million in one-time merger expenses and goodwill, the EPS loss was ($0.30). Amazon.com continues to state that it would plow any revenue greater than its internal estimates back into the business. They also stated that they will only do so if appropriate investments present themselves. Amazon.com's strong balance sheet allows the company to pursue this aggressive strategy due to its total cash and marketable securities balance of $373 million.
Outlook
In brief, we are raising our 1999 revenue numbers and increasing our loss per share estimates while establishing our full year 2000 estimates. Our new estimates are as follows: 1Q Revenues of $255 million (was $200 million), and FY 1999 revenues of $1.24 billion (was $930 million). Due to the expected increase in product development costs in the first half of 1999 and flat gross margin conditions, we are lowering our1999 EPS estimate to ($0.93) from ($0.58). For the year 2000 we are looking for $1.7 billion in revenues. As Amazon.com begins to realize the leverage in the operating model, we expect revenue growth to outstrip expense growth and lower the loss per share to ($0.27) for 2000. Our per-share loss estimates are detailed on page one of this note. |