Ray,
>hot dipped galvanized is far more practical from an estimator's perspective.<
The hot dipped galvanized variant is used in those locations downtown where street vendors are licensed to operate their culinary businesses through the use of sidewalk stands. It has been found to resist the saline residue buildup that occurs in the underground due to vendors who recklessly dispose of their perishable liquid waste matter at the end of the business day.
Large deposits of sodium x-fates are found to collect in soluble form at certain temperatures during the summer months. Worse than petrol drippings, these solutions seep into anything with even the slightest osmotic qualities. They are the result of hot dog vendors who do a daily run off of their liquid remains onto sidewalks and street curbs, for lack of any more feasible means of removal. Not pretty, not appetizing. Not good for copper circuit splice points. =====
In 1976, when the four-tone method of nonlinear distortion was formalized for Bell-approved transmission impairment measuring sets (TIMS), I was working with the Labs evaluating HP vs Halcyon, along with some folks in Pactel's San Diego offices doing the same thing.
During these trials I was called upon to examine a thorny problem by one of the special services bureaus. After diagnosing the problem as Harmonic Distortion, I referred it to the appropriate repair center. Eventually I reported it to Bell Labs, as well, when it finally dawned on me that the harmonic distortion was actually manifesting itself on an all-metallic circuit.
No repeaters, no switch ports, no carrier channel units. Just wire. I didn't know what could have possibly been causing it. And I was in much less of a position to recommend a remedy. So I called the Labs.
This was a line that extended from the Broad Street C.O., which serves the NY Stock Exchange, to a Chinatown bank branch about a mile uptown. It was served out of 32 Avenue of the Americas, the ATT Long Lines HQ building, where a NY Tel end office also resided.
The circuit had been a frequent repeat offender. Typical clearances on the trouble reports read as follows: no trouble found, cleared away while testing, swinging open, intermittent noise, customer error, customer smoking dope, etc. It was that kind of frustrating situation.
The circuit could satisfactorily pass data at 2400 bps, but not at 4800 or above. [This was at a time when 9600 b/s was really smokin', and used for extraordinary requirements, only. At the time, modems were priced at about a dollar per bit. Today, they run about a dollar fifty per kilobit.]
Each time a craftsman (tester) got up on the line to test it, it seemed to miraculously come clear, i.e., the trouble vanished. This was due to the 106 vdc [breakdown-causing] voltage which was applied at the time of test. This phenomenon has otherwise been referred to, from time to time, as "zapping" the line. It was the epitome of ballistic testing until low voltage test sets were finally mandated for special services test situations.
I was expertly familiar with other threshold syndromes, whereby data lines could pass traffic up to a certain bit rate, and then no more. Especially when it occurred on the older T carrier terminals whose expanders and compressors were non-hardened (read: unstable semiconductors causing nonlinear distortion). But I had never seen it before on circuits which were purely copper-based metallic, end to end.
The message circuit noise was nil, and there were no bridged taps. No need to check for phase jitter, or dropouts, these were not indicated. There was only this very, very bad signal-to-noise ratio being caused by nonlinear distortion on an all-metallic circuit. And it went away, not too surprisingly when you think about it, for a while, when it was zapped. It later returned, like clockwork.
The mere fact that it had no active components on it caused the Labs folks to throw it back at me, suggesting that perhaps it was I who was smoking dope. Hmph! At that point I turned to using a Bradley Telecom phasor domain line analyzer, and sure enough there was this large three-leaf clover smack in the middle of the tube registering 19 db separation.
With a fundamental to third order harmonic product clearly visible, the Bradley unit showed six lobes, actually two sets of three lobes folded back onto themselves, which had a resultant effect of appearing like a three-leaf clover. The test clearly indicated a dominant presence of a third order harmonic. Suddenly, with a Polaroid of this pattern in my hand and shipped to Holmdel, I had the attention of the Labs.
The diagnosis? Semiconductor p-n buildup on a good & plenty splice point caused by salination and oxidation of same in a hostile street environment. Resolution? None. Actually, we were going to administer sealing current, but we wound up changing the pair instead, because the customer was making higher management level calls by that point, and couldn't waste any more time. We wound up making the offending pair (a.k.a., the salty dog) available for burglar alarm circuits which had constant voltage on them, anyway.
We never received another report from that branch office again concerning the circuit in question.
Frank_C.
ps - I was only kidding about the Hot DoG merchants. |