This is just in- ------------------------------- 08:00am EST 21-Feb-97 Alex Brown (G. G. HUNT) NN CSCC NNC.CA NNC NN/CSCC:FRAME RELAY STILL A HEALTHY MARKET--..BUY George G. Hunt (415) 477-4287 February 20, 1997 Alex. Brown NEWBRIDGE NETWORKS CORPORATION/NASDAQ (NN) CASCADE COMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION/NASDAQ (CSCC) Frame Relay Still A Healthy Market-- Maintaining Current Estimates And "Buy" Ratings
Analyst 52-Wk Stock Price Price FY Earnings Per Share Cal. Yr. P/E Indicated Ticker Rating 2/20/97 Range End 1996A 1997E 1998E 1997E 1998E Div. Yield
NN 2 33 3/8 37-20 4 $0.87 $1.07 $1.35 26.5x NM $0.00 Nil CSCC 2 30 91-30 12 $0.73 $1.10 $1.55 27.3x 19.4x $0.00 Nil NN CY 1997 EPS estimate is $1.26. SUMMARY -- We expect 1997 to be a banner year for frame relay. -- We do not believe carriers are experiencing a slowdown in frame relay demand, which is highlighted in the enclosed frame relay/ATM carrier matrix. -- Frame relay, according to Vertical Systems, will increase from a $1.35 billion market in 1996 to a $3 billion market in 1999. -- Cascade is the frame relay market share leader but it does not control the market. -- Newbridge reported strong frame results for the quarter ending January 24, 1997. -- Carriers are currently in the port provisioning cycle and we believe will add additional infrastructure equipment in 2Q-3Q, 1997. -- ATM and frame relay are not mutually exclusive alternatives--most networks are a combination of both. -- We are reiterating our current Newbridge estimates of FY (Apr.) 1997 revenues of $1.29 billion (+40%) generating EPS of $1.07 versus $0.87 and FY:98 estimates revenues of $1.69 billion (+31%) generating EPS of $1.35 and Cascade estimates of 1997 revenues of $560 million (+64%) generating EPS of $1.10 versus $0.73 and 1998 estimates of revenues of $803.5 million (+44%) generating EPS of $1.55. Both stocks remain rated "buy."
DETAIL -- We expect 1997 to be a banner year for frame relay - Although the rate of frame relay growth is decreasing due to the law of large numbers, subscriber demand is stronger than ever before. Applications that are expected to drive frame relay demand in 1997 include international growth of frame relay, voice and SNA over frame relay, and high-speed T3 (45 Mbps) frame relay service offerings from carriers. -- We do not believe carriers are experiencing a slowdown in frame relay demand - Independent research highlighted in the following matrix indicates carriers will add more frame relay ports in 1997 than was the case in any previous year. -- Frame relay is a very healthy market - The frame relay market, according to Vertical Systems, will grow from $1.35 billion in 1996 to $3.07 billion in 1999. In the most recent survey of North American frame relay users, Vertical Systems reports that every client surveyed planned to add more than 2x the number of frame relay ports in 1997 versus the case in 1996. -- Cascade is the frame relay market share leader but it does not control the market - Cascade dominates the RBOC frame relay market with 4 of the 6 RBOCs and GTE as frame relay customers but does not have a presence in the big 3 IXC marketplace (AT&T, MCI, and Sprint) or international (21% of 4Q:96 revenues were international). According to Vertical Systems, Cascade has a 23.3% worldwide market share with Cisco/StrataCom #2 at 20.8%, Nortel #3 at 7.9%, and Newbridge #4 at 7.7% Cascade is the market leader, but with less than a 25% market share it does not control the frame relay market. -- Newbridge reported strong frame relay results on February 18 for the quarter ending January 24, 1997. Frame relay order intake for F3Q 1997 increased by approximately 45% compared with the levels in the previous quarter. Frame relay 36170 sales accounted for more than 20% of the total 36170 product revenue, which represents a doubling of frame relay sales over the previous quarter's levels. In the Newbridge quarterly conference call yesterday, the company stated that while it was seeing a slowdown of frame relay at ISPs and in single-purpose frame relay products (products that support frame relay only), it was not seeing a slowdown in frame relay demand from carriers, especially for multipurpose platforms that support frame relay and ATM on the same switch. We note that frame relay and ATM offered on the same switch is only an advantage if there is no performance penalty to support both services. The 36170, which supports up to 8 shelves with 1.6 Gbps switching capacity per shelf, has the processing power to support both frame relay and ATM on the same switch. We believe this feature is an advantage for carriers and will be particularly attractive to ISPs, which we believe are migrating from frame relay to ATM, and in third world countries where infrastructure is not yet in place (offering frame and ATM on the same switch will be a migration and cost advantage here). Newbridge management also stated in the conference call that it believes it is capturing frame relay market share. -- Carriers are currently in the port provisioning cycle - We believe carriers are currently in the port provisioning cycle and are signing up users on their existing infrastructure equipment and will add infrastructure switches in the second and third calendar quarters of 1997 to gear up for the next wave of demand for frame relay. -- ATM and frame relay are not mutually exclusive alternatives - Carriers are installing frame relay in their core networks to trunk large amount of leased line and frame relay traffic. Frame relay switches are also being added as access switches and backbone switches surrounding the core ATM switches. Frame relay and ATM function well together in the same network. Very few networks are all ATM or all frame relay with most being a combination of both. -- We are reiterating our current Newbridge estimates of FY:97 revenues of $1.29 billion (+40%) generating EPS of $1.07 versus $0.87 and FY:98 estimates revenues of $1.69 billion (+31%) generating EPS of $1.35 and Cascade estimates of 1997 revenues of $560 million (+64%) generating EPS of $1.10 versus $0.73 and 1998 estimates of revenues of $803.5 million (+44%) generating EPS of $1.55. Both stocks remain rated "buy."
Carrier Frame Relay ATM Service Offering Service Offering AT&T Cisco/StrataCom Lucent Globe View 2000; BPX/AXIS Final ATM vendor not selected
Frame Relay Capacity Plans --Network expands by 100% every 18 months --Strong demand for frame relay --grew from 15,000 ports in 1994 to 50,000 ports in 1995 --grew from 50,000 ports in 1995 to 100,000 ports in 1996 --projected to grow from 100,000 ports in 1996 to 200,000 ports in 1997
MCI Domestic- GDC APEX Bay Networks routers; Nortel Vector International- StrataCom IGX --Frame relay network growth peaked in June of 1996 --Still adding frame relay ports but at a slower rate --ATM growth second half of 1997 --ATM will find market share at all speeds
Sprint Alcatel NEC/Hitachi --Strong demand for frame relay --Frame relay ports will increase 50% in 1997 LDDS/ Cascade 9000 Cisco/StrataCom WorldCom AXIS/BPX --Strong demand for frame relay --ATM demand in 1998
Ameritech Lucent Globe View 2000 Lucent Globe View 2000 NYNEX Newbridge 36150 Cascade 500 Bell Cascade 9000 Cascade 500 Atlantic --Strong demand for frame relay --grew from 4,000 ports in 1995 to 12,000 ports in 1996 --projected to grow from 12,000 ports in 1996 to 24,000 ports in 1997
Bell South Cascade 9000 Fujitsu 150 U S West Cascade 9000 Newbridge 36170 --Strong demand for frame relay --grew from 14,000 ports in 1994 to 24,000 ports in 1995 --grew from 24,000 ports in 1995 to 40,000 ports in 1996 --projected to grow 40,000 ports in 1996 to 60,000 ports in 1997
SW Bell Newbridge 36150 Fujitsu 150 --Strong demand for frame relay --grew from 2,800 ports in 1995 to 5,700 ports in 1996 --projected to grow from 5,700 ports in 1996 to 8,800 ports in 1997 Pac Bell Cascade 9000 Newbridge 36170 Newbridge 36150 GTE Cascade 9000 Newbridge 36170 Additional Information Available Upon Request Alex. Brown & Sons Incorporated maintains a net primary market in the common stock of Cascade Communications Corporation. Within the past three years, Alex. Brown & Sons Incorporated has managed or comanaged a public offering of Cascade Communications Corporation. Cascade Communications Corporation and Newbridge Networks stocks are optionable. The author of this comment has a long position in the common shares of Cascade Communications Corporation. First Call Corporation - all rights reserved. 617/345-2500
-> End of Note <- |