I have been over this terrain exhaustively with E.V. (I don't spell out his name, because i understand he searches for it, and that that might attract him.)
The history of intercommunal antagonism in the period before Christians got hold of the Roman state and empire shows only the normal antagonisms attendant on the competitive separation of two religious groups, with the exception of an obscure set of riots in Alexandria in which Christians and other groups were attacked by Jews, there is no basis, none, for asserting that Jews initiated campaigns of physical violence against Christians.
There is, however, a long and deep literature of historical calumny making this claim. This literature has been subject to overwhelming scholarly deconstruction and has been discredited in detail. The story is told compactly in James Parkes's, The conflict of the Church and the Synagogue, A Study in the Origins of Antisemitism.
The great unending persecutions of the Jews by Christians, of course, unfold following the Christianizing of the Roman state, when the tool of legislation came into the hands of leaders disposed to believe lies about the Jews and about the origins of their own beliefs.
An obvious point: Jews were never able to take out their anger against Christians through state power. They had no state.
Any specific allegation of a Jewish pogrom against Christians you might want to present as 'evidence' I would be happy to comment on. Please be specific. Please point out any passages in the relevant portions of the New Testament, Acts - Revelation, that allege Jewish, not Roman, killing of Christians.
N. |
