This is kind of entertaining. Tom posted this the other day, in regards to his Q3test benchmarking which Brian said is inaccurate:
--------------
"This Brian Hook, or 'Grandmaster B', as he likes to call himself very modestly, has said a whole lot in the past, some of it was true, other stuff wasn't. 'Timedemo' DOES work if you do it right, and Brian is unfortunately incorrect. Sorry Brian, but even 'Grandmaster B' is not perfect"
--------------
Of course, Brain, being just as arrogant as Tom (and that's saying something :-) ), couldn't let this slide. From today's Ask GMB column:
--------------
I've seen those comments, and I think they pretty much speak for themselves. My track record speaks for itself within this industry, and unlike others, I don't have a resume that basically consists of "I've done a lot of HTML, therefore I must know my shit, right?". I actually do this stuff for a living, so maybe I'm not full of shit. And I don't advertise products that I'm also reviewing on my Web page. I don't make ANY money from Grandmaster B ads or from .plan files, so you know there's no conflict of interest when I tell it like it is. I do not own any shares of stock in 3D accelerator companies, so there's no conflict there.
When I write this stuff, I do it because I enjoy it and because I like to educate others. It's that simple. It's not a job, it's not something I have to do to feed my dogs or pay off my car. I do it for the love of writing, communication, and education. It's that simple.
Tom's numbers might be valid. Then again, they might not. There's some variability there, depending on how paranoid you are about his advertiser revenue affecting his findings.
But all that is irrelevant -- what is going to happen now is that id will publish authoritative numbers using up to date drivers and production hardware. Those numbers will be the unarguable truth, using the most up to date code possible. There will be no illicit overclocking, no conflict of interest, and no advertiser revenue from chip manufacturers to dilute any discovery.
Tom's comments about _me_ are irrelevant -- pissing matches over personalities are pretty much useless, people will take sides over who they like the most and rarely will listen to the issues. In the end, what matters is getting good, honest numbers to the public, and that is something that id has promised will be around Real Soon Now. |
