To: MikeM54321 who wrote (6670 ) 6/11/1999 11:51:00 AM From: Chuzzlewit Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 9068
Mike you noted:Secondly, what do you make of CTXS doing a convertible offering raising around $300 million, then turning right around and authorizing a share buyback of $200 million? Not that I'm saying anything is wrong with it, but the timing is unusual. In your opinion would a company actually plan for this type of transaction? If so, you would have thought that they wouldn't have done a "convertible," right? First, let me start with one financial facts of life: a share repurchase is a tax advantaged dividend in disguise. Were taxes not an issue, shareholders would get the same benefit by using the $200 million to purchase additional shares. But since the company is doing it for them the "dividend" is tax-deferred, and when the share holder eventually sells it is treated as a capital gain rather than ordinary income. So now, the question that needs to be asked is why did the company authorize a dividend (in the form of a share repurchase) at all? In general, a company ought to be investing its cash in productive assets. In the case of CTXS I would think that this ought to be in the form of software development investments. In general terms, a company ought to dividend cash to shareholders when no financially feasible investments are available. This approach is called the "residual dividend" policy. Thus, the fact that the company decided to expend $200 million for share repurchase raises a question in my mind as to whether this is the best use of cash. Next, the company issues debt with a face value of around $300 MM. Now this would be alright, because in effect the company would have simply made the decision to leverage itself -- issue debt and use the proceeds to buy stock. The sticking point is the fact that they used convertible debt to accomplish the leverage. This begins to smack of financial engineering. The reason is that if the price of the stock is below the conversion price trigger then the extra shares that would be counted by dilution won't appear on a fully diluted basis. They will appear only if the price of the stock is above the trigger. And in that case, on a fully diluted basis the accumulated interest will be backed out of the computation (remember, these are zero coupon bonds), which will raise the total earnings. TTFN, CTC