To: KeepItSimple who wrote (66349 ) 7/5/1999 8:43:00 PM From: dbblg Respond to of 164684
>>The market, and nothing else, is keeping our economy afloat. Consumer saving has dropped below zero, consumer spending is at an all time high, and credit card debt is at an all time high as well. The only thing keeping the economy going is the wealth created through the stock market. Repeating this over and over won't make it true. 1. "Consumer savings" is extrapolated from figures on estimated income and estimated expenditures. Short term capital gains taxes are counted as expenditures, but short term capital gains aren't included as income. Skews the figures. Personal savings have trended down somewhat, especially considering how low the unemployment rate is, but the situation is not nearly as dire as the media has suggested. 2. The wealth effect from stock appreciation is dwarfed by the wealth effect from the real estate bubble. There are two components to this, one short-term, and one long. First, the low nominal interest rates last fall encouraged lots of people to refinance their mortgages. Many of them took money out to buy cars, pay down consumer debt, etc. Second--and this is something which I find very worrying, longer term--the capital gains tax rules on primary residences were relaxed dramatically two years ago. Now that people don't have to roll profits into a more expensive home when they sell, a big chunk of that money is undoubtedly entering both the real economy and the financial markets. By contrast, most people plow their stock market gains back into the market. This is not true of company founders, etc., who cash out their options, but that represents a relatively small part of the economy--though I recognize it may look different from Palo Alto. 3. There are irrationally exuberant investors on all sides of all trades in all markets. Both the "AOL Happy Dancers" you cite, as well as the "AMZN grave dancers" will likely get cleaned out if they press their bets too far or leverage themselves too heavily. Last summer and fall I made more money on the short side than I ever thought possible, and began to see 1929 in the charts. There was a week I was short MER, IBM, GE, and LEH. I escaped with modest profits in three (and a modest loss in MER) largely out of sheer dumb luck; I closed everything out before going on a long overseas trip...