To: slacker711 who wrote (131 ) 7/24/1999 5:53:00 PM From: Ramsey Su Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 13582
A word of thanks to all. This new thread is absolutely unbelievable. There are more good stuff on here in a few short days than probably the last month combined. The only "problem" now is - reading them takes time and requires some thinking. :-) slacker711, Idler, Bob Craig, etc, regarding the H&Q report - Message 10630240 I have a hard copy and it shows some of the numbers not show on Bob Craig's reformatted report. It is quite apparent that it is a pure hit piece. I have to wonder, with the timing and the data they presented, was H&Q upset that Lehman and GS got the 6.9 million shares offering and they were squeezed out? There are only 2 conclusions one can draw from their earnings estimates going forward. First, the H&Q conclusions were all drawn before listening to the earnings conference call last Monday. The other conclusion is H&Q thinks QC management, namely Thornley, was lying when he said to use $.86 proforma this qtr as base going forward. Now how do you get an estimate of $2.70 for FY2000, when the company tells you that they think $.86 is the base for a seasonally weak qtr? Even if you do a simple $.86 X 4, it is still $3.44. Anyway, the entire report was focused on one subject - over capacity. In summary, H&Q believes the CALENDAR 1999 aggregate global demand for handsets is 33,362,000 while the aggregate supply for handsets is 44,700,000 . If you believe these numbers, than handset supply exceeds demand by 34% for 1999. Further more, reading the report gives you the impression that QC is purely a handset manufacturer. ASICs and other stuff are pure sidelines. Regarding ASP, while H&Q projected erosion going forward, they made no actual projection of demand. This could be a huge mistake since China is nowhere to be found on the 1999 demand estimates and Japan's demand for 1999 is only 4.740 million. Despite the fact that the H&Q conclusions are pure trash, motivated by reasons knownst only to H&Q management, the report itself is a keeper and very useful as a check list. It is very unfortunate that H&Q decided, for whatever reason, have chosen to trash QC. One may never understand the hidden motivations of these Wall Streeters. Ramsey