SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Technology Stocks : The New Qualcomm - a S&P500 company -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: marginmike who wrote (138)7/24/1999 2:01:00 PM
From: Ron M  Respond to of 13582
 
A technical comparison of 3G alternates lifted from

cudenver.edu

Hell, I don't understand it I thought someone here might find it useful. Format is much better at the link.

TABLE I: ARIB/ETSI/cdma2000 Comparison Table




Japan (ARIB)
Europe (ETSI)
U.S. (cdma2000)
MA Scheme
WB DS-CDMA
Duplex Scheme
FDD & TDD
Channel Spacing
1.25/ 5.0/10.0/20.0 MHz
5.0/10.0/20.0 MHz
1.25 MHz
Chip Rate
1.024/4.096/
8.192/16.384 Mcps
4.096/8.192/
16.384 Mcps
1.23/3.69/
7.37/11.1/14.7 Mcps
Frame Length
10 ms
5 & 20 ms
Inter BS Synchronization
none
synchronized
Spreading Modulation ? Forward
Complex-QPSK
QPSK
Complex-QPSK
multicarrier optional
Spreading Modulation - Reverse
Complex-QPSK
Complex-QPSK
Pulse shaping
Root-raised cosine (RRC),
IS-95 - B
Scrambling Codes ? Forward

(cellsite ID)
Partial GOLD code

(1 frame; order 19)
IS-95-B
short m-sequences (length 2^15)

(phase identifies base)
Scrambling Codes ? Reverse
Partial GOLD code

(36,864 frames)
Partial GOLD code

(1 frame; order 41)
IS-95-B

short m-sequences (length 2^15)

XOR

IS-95-B, long m-sequences

(length 2^41; mobile ID)
User identification - Forward
OVSF channelization code assignment is user specific
long m-sequences XOR with data

(length 2^41)
User identification - Reverse
Reverse GOLD scrambling code is user specific
long m-sequences XOR with
scrambling code (length 2^41)
Channelization Codes ? Forward
OVSF (Walsh family)
variable length Walsh codes
Channelization Codes ? Reverse

(mobile ID)
OVSF (Walsh family)
variable length Walsh codes
Data Modulation - Forward
QPSK
QPSK
Data Modulation - Reverse
BPSK
QPSK
BPSK
Data Rates Supported
kbps

4.096 Mbps max

, , and

1036.8 and 2073.6 kbps

also, kbps, ,

2.0736 Mbps max
Pilot Channel Strategy
time-multiplex
code-multiplex (common or
auxiliary)
Data Demodulation


coh. using time multiplex pilot
symbols & possibly pilot carrier
coherent using time multiplex
pilot symbols
coherent using continuous code
multiplex pilot
Error Control
convolutional code
(<32 kbps)

turbo codes (>32 kbps)
convolutional code,

concatenated RS & CC,

turbo codes
Convol. code (K=9;
=1/2,3/8,1/3,1/4)
(<14.1 kbps)

turbo codes (K=4, R=1/2,1/3,1/4)
(>14.4 kbps)
Interleaving Depth
10, 20, or 80 ms
10, 20, 40, 80 ms
20 ms
Power Control
Forward & Reverse
Forward & Reverse
Power Control Rate
1600 Hz
800 Hz
Power Control Delay
1 time slot


Power Control Step
1 dB
0.25-1.5 dB
0.25, 0.5, 1.0 dB
Power Control Range - Forward
TBD
30 dB
128 dB

+/- 24 dB (fast)
Power Control Range - Reverse
TBD
80 dB
128 dB (??) +/- 24 dB (fast)
Multi-Rate Strategy
shortened Walsh codes

and multicode
shortened Walsh codes and
"supplemental" channels
(multicode)

Abbreviations used: BPSK: biphase-shift keying

CDMA: code-division multiple access

DS: direct sequence

FDD: frequency-division duplex

ID: identification

kbps: kilobits per second

Mcps: megachips per second

MHz: megahertz

ms: millisecond

OVSF: orthogonal variable spreading factor

QPSK: quadrature phase-shift keying

RRC: root-raised cosine

TDD: time-division duplex

WB: wideband

XOR: exclusive-OR