To: Dorine Essey who wrote (142277 ) 9/19/1999 5:49:00 AM From: Lancer Respond to of 176387
Dorine-about IBM from Reuter business news: IBM Falls On Analyst Caution Over Q3 By Eric Auchard NEW YORK (Reuters) - Shares of International Business Machines Corp., the world's largest computer maker, slid as much as $6 after a Merrill Lynch analyst trimmed his estimate for hardware revenue growth in the third-quarter. In a note to clients, analyst Steve Milunovich said he had cut his estimate for hardware sales growth in the September quarter to 4 percent from 6 percent. His concern over possible slowing computer hardware sales could well set the pace for the way dealers view upcoming earnings for many high-tech companies. He cut estimates due to difficult comparisons with strong year-ago results in its mainframe and personal computer businesses, which constitute the bulk of IBM hardware sales. IBM stock, leading the New York Stock Exchange's most active list, recovered somewhat in heavy late-afternoon trading to end the day down $4-5/8 at $125-3/8, returning to the range within which it traded during August's doldrums, before it began a recent surge toward spring's record level of $139. The top Merrill technology analyst said he was still confident overall IBM revenues and earnings would be in line with current expectations, but worried that investors could react to the sluggish hardware growth and exit the stock after the third-quarter results are published in mid-October. ``We believe earnings will be reported essentially in line with our expectations but we think there may be a quality of earnings issues in 4Q (fourth quarter) and the stock could react negatively,' he wrote, referring to the hardware concerns. He maintained his buy rating on the stock. However, other analysts questioned what was new in Merrill's numbers, since most brokerage have calculated low single-digit revenue growth into their hardware estimates. Kevin McCarthy, an analyst with Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette, said he was only counting on 3.6 percent hardware growth in the third quarter, but 8 to 9 percent growth in overall revenues during the same period. ``I really don't know if anybody had anything different,' McCarthy said referring to how Wall Street's general consensus has been to expect low-single digit growth for IBM hardware sales and high single-digit rates for overall revenues. Milunovich kept his earnings estimate of 91 cents per share for the computer maker's third quarter, in line with McCarthy's view, and the consensus among Wall Street analysts in general, according to a recent Thomson Financial/First Call survey. The influential Merrill Lynch analyst said his concern about hardware growth centered on mainframe revenues which are likely to be down more than 10 percent this quarter. ``This does not surprise us because the company is facing difficult comps,' he said, using financial shorthand that refers to comparisons with the year-ago period, when IBM introduced its hot-selling G5 mainframe series, making relative gains in growth more difficult to achieve. ``Typically investors react to hardware numbers when IBM reports results, which is why we are a bit concerned,' he said. While noting that over the long-term he believes IBM's computer services and software will drive the company's performance, ``On a quarterly basis, hardware appears to drive the numbers,' he said. ``We think investors may focus on a mediocre hardware growth number of 4 percent in the quarter.' He also said he was concerned by the performance of IBM's AS/400 minicomputer line, machines that typically are targeted to run the key business operations of mid-sized businesses. While McCarthy said he believed investors had overreacted to Merrill's report, he noted that IBM faces an air of uncertainty heading into the end of this year, when corporate computer buyers -- IBM's bread-and-butter customers -- may hold back on new purchases to fix possible Year 2000 glitches. ``I do think that during the October conference call their will be caution in the air,' he said referring to the quarterly conference call IBM executives typically hold with Wall Street on the heels of financial reports. The third-quarter report is due out the week of October 20. Reut00:23 09-19-99 Best regards - Luciano