To: rudedog who wrote (145331 ) 10/20/1999 11:37:00 AM From: Ian@SI Respond to of 176387
DELL: 3Q00 SHORTFALL; REITERATE BUY AND $60 TARGET Dell Computer Corp(DELL) Rating: 1H 10/19/1999 Salomon Smith Barney ~ October 19, 1999 10/19/99 Dell Computer (DELL $41.31,1-H,Tgt $60.00) Richard Gardner --SUMMARY:--Dell Computer--PCs *Dell announced a 10% EPS shortfall for the October quarter yesterday after the close. The shortfall is attributable to a sharp rise in DRAM memory prices at the end of the quarter. While Dell's memory prices doubled between early July and last week, Dell was able to manage through these earlier increases--another 25% spike in prices last week was the final straw. *We are lowering 3Q00 EPS from $0.20 to $0.18 and 4Q00 EPS from $0.22 to $0.21. Our changes are entirely attributable to lower than expected gross margin--we have not changed our revenue estimates. Management continues to cite strong overall demand. *Reiterate Buy (1H) rating and $60 target. We would be aggressive buyers of Dell shares below $40. 10/19/99 Dell Computer (DELL $41.31,1-H,Tgt $60.00) Richard Gardner --FUNDAMENTALS-------------------------------------------------------------- Current Rank........:1H Prior:No Change Price (10/18/99)....:$41.31 P/E Ratio 01/00.....:55.8x Target Price..:$60.00 Prior:No Change P/E Ratio 01/01.....:39.7x Proj.5yr EPS Grth...:25.0% Return on Eqty 99...:89.0% Book Value/Shr(00)..:1.29 LT Debt-to-Capital(a)N/A% Dividend............:$N/A Revenue (00)........:24329.00mil Yield...............:N/A% Shares Outstanding..:2784.0mil Convertible.........:No Mkt. Capitalization.:115007.0mil Hedge Clause(s).....: Comments............:(a) Data as of the most recently reported quarter. Comments............: 10/19/99 Dell Computer (DELL $41.31,1-H,Tgt $60.00) --OPINION:------------------------------------------------------------------ CEO Michael Dell and CFO Tom Meredith hosted yesterday's call. Meredith began the call with extremely upbeat comments regarding both demand and component availability. He characterized overall PC demand as very strong, and said that the company is even more comfortable with the current demand outlook than it was during August's upbeat earnings conference call. On the component front, Meredith commented that availability is improving, even for flat panel displays which have been constrained for several quarters. At the company's recent analyst meeting, Meredith expressed his belief that Dell would be experience minimal top line impact from Taiwan-related and other component constraints during both 3Q00 and 4Q00 and Meredith reaffirmed this belief during yesterday's call. Meredith attributed the likely shortfall during 3Q00 to a sharp rise in DRAM prices at the end of the quarter. While Dell's contract price for DRAM doubled between early July and last week, the company had apparently been able to manage through these earlier increases via the combination of normal price declines in other component categories and the management of other component costs. Last week, however, Dell's DRAM suppliers informed the company of an additional 25% price hike which did not leave the company sufficient time to absorb the increase. Meredith quantified the impact as a $70-75 per box increase in cost of goods sold applicable to 30-35% of the company's total unit shipments during the October quarter. This reduces our gross margin for the October quarter from 21.6% to 20.4% (versus 22.0% in the July quarter) and our EPS from $0.20 to $0.18. According to Meredith, there will not be any significant reduction in operating expenses to offset the gross margin shortfall. In response to continued DRAM price hikes, Dell intends to reduce the amount of memory per system. Meredith sounded optimistic about Dell's ability to manage through further increases in DRAM pricing during the fourth quarter and still deliver consensus EPS. We are lowering our 4Q00 EPS estimate from $0.22 to $0.21 to reflect a more gradual recovery in gross margins. OUTLOOK It is important to note that we have not changed our revenue estimates for Dell's third and fourth fiscal quarters. We do not believe that yesterday's announcement is indicative of a deterioration in demand or in Dell's relative competitive position. The only significant risk to our current revenue estimates for Dell, in our view, is component availability issues related to Taiwan, but Dell management seems increasingly comfortable with its ability to obtain the components that it needs to maintain the company's current revenue trajectory. Moreover, we believe that overall demand for personal computers will remain robust during the fourth quarter despite recent increases in components pricing. If there is an adverse impact on demand, we believe this impact will occur at the low-end of the market where Dell does not have a presence. Michael Dell and Tom Meredith also remain optimistic about technology drivers during the fourth quarter, such as Pentium III-based notebooks and 8X server configurations. Management reiterated its belief that Y2K is not and will not have a significant impact on the company's ability to achieve prior expectations. While there may be a slowing in demand from some of Dell's large accounts in vertical markets such as Banking and Securities, we believe that Dell's rapid diversification into new markets like consumer, small to mid-sized business, China, services, high-end servers and storage will be sufficient to offset a slowing in some accounts. Michael Lambert, Senior VP of Dell's Server and Storage Division, cited no impact from Y2K on the overall growth of his business relative to expectations. In summary, Meredith characterized this quarter's shortfall as a unique set of events that are not likely to be repeated for some time. Meredith expressed his belief that DRAM suppliers have raised prices to the point where they risk a significant decrease in demand for their product over a 6-9 month period. Once DRAM configurations are adjusted downward, rambus comes to market and major DRAM manufacturers complete the transition to .18 micron process technology, Meredith believes that DRAM prices are likely to resume their normal downward trajectory. We reiterate our Buy rating on Dell shares and our $60 target. We view this as a temporary situation, and one which does not speak to the overall health of PC demand or to Dell's relative competitive position. As we said following Dell's recent analyst meeting, we are extremely comfortable with the company's strategic positioning and the status of its diversification efforts. We would be aggressive buyers of Dell shares below $40. ------------