To: Johnny Canuck who wrote (24402 ) 11/20/1999 3:31:00 PM From: Gary Martin Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 69866
Hi All, I wrote to ask the members of this thread a technical question which may be a little off the "hot" subjects you are discussing. I've started using Welles Wilder's "Directional Movement Indicator" as I found it recently on CQG's service for futures trading. The indicator shown by CQG does not match the description of DMI as shown in one of my 6-year old technical analysis manuals. This newer, current version has three lines, +DMI, -DMI and ATR a version of Wilder's ADX)and provides a crossover signal when the lines make that pattern. (The older version took the difference in the lines and made a histogram with bars above and below a zero line.) My questions are based on the fact that I started trading using the "new crossover" DMI and it looks good on (currently)less volatile markets such as Wheat and other Agricultural markets. However, I am using the indicator based on a different interpretation than recommended by Wilder in a synopsis I read from his book "New Concepts in Technical Trading Systems". But, when I follow his recommended approach for using the indicator in the S&P futures, it looks like it is right 2 out of three times it makes a signal. So, I am seeing my interpretation work with low volatility markets, and Wilder's recommendation work in high volatility markets (anyway, that's what I think I'm seeing!) If I didn't confuse you all with the proceeding too badly, I would like to ask if anyone has any experience with the DMI in high volatile and/or lower volatility markets? Has anyone been able to compare the application of the DMI in different markets? Also, does anyone have the new DMI in a software package? (I have the older version in an AIQ program from the mid 1990's.) Thanks. Gary