To: John Busby who wrote (99 ) 11/23/1999 8:21:00 AM From: John Biddle Respond to of 3372
The priority/non-priority approach sounds like my 2B idea except that you have designated a thread as the priority thread and I was leaving the user to select the thread into which he/she wanted new marked threads to go as uncharacterized. The Main/subcategories is what I meant when I referred to a master page in 2A. Same idea different names. You seem to favor the one click approach. It is faster initially, but is more work overall because to finish categorizing a thread the member will have to switch active bookmarks pages, select the thread to move, and then select the bookmarks page to move it to. In my favored alternative approach, when the member clicks once to bookmark a thread, he/she would be asked which of the bookmarks pages to move it to. This is much more intuitive for the member, since they're already thinking of why they are bookmarking the thread in the first place. It is also significantly less work for the member as well as being a one-and-done approach wherein the housekeeping is not left for later. If the member is not maintaining more than one page of bookmarks, then don't ask which one to move it to and it will be the same as it is now. I may be wrong here, but the immediate categorization approach does not seem to be more programming effort either. The routines to list the bookmarks pages a member has, get a selection from that user, and add the thread to the selected page will have to be written anyway. You will need them for enabling existing users to move some of their currently marked threads to their new page(s). For your questionnaire: I have 52 threads bookmarked.