To: CJ who wrote (39 ) 12/9/1999 12:56:00 AM From: Jeffrey S. Mitchell Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 1397
I guess what I'm trying to say is essentially there are two ways to solve a murder: 1) Make a list of all the relevant people you can find and try to fit them to the crime, or 2) Analyze the crime and look for people that might fit it. Option 1 is how most of us are used to solving a crime. After all, when we read a murder mystery we know at some point we've run into the killer; it's just a question of who. In good mystery novels, just about anyone could be the killer if we think hard enough. What I'm saying is we have to fight this instinct because it's dangerous. To reiterate, unless a suspect has an airtight alibi you can always find a reason why they may have been the killer. Option 2 is (I'm pretty sure) called profiling. Here you figure out the most likely scenario, i.e. where all the clues likely lead. Then you search for people who fit that description. For example, I made an argument that the police searched Jim's car and found no evidence Suzanne had ever been in it nor any evidence he had it cleaned inside or out. You said you thought it was possible for someone to get in a car and not leave evidence. Of course that is possible, but the point is is it probable? Wouldn't there most likely be fingerprints on the outside of the door, on the inside of the door, on the dashboard, etc.? I know I'm being stubborn here, and I know I'm coming off as somewhat impolite, but, hey, I agree that every one of us here can probably come up with a different possible scenario on how Jim could be the killer, especially sharp people like you :). Likewise, if we threw in any one her friends that didn't have an airtight alibi I'm sure we could argue they were jealous of her or some such nonsense. I'm hoping we can take an Occam's Razor approach -- that the most likely scenario is indeed what happened -- and see where it takes us. So, in conclusion, all I'm really saying is that more often than not I contend 1) most people entering and exiting a car leave some sort of evidence behind they've been there, and 2) murder suspects who allow the police to search their cars without first thoroughly cleaning them usually indicate they have nothing to hide. - Jeff