Buffett won't beat the market this year By David Pauly, Bloomberg
NEW YORK -- In his annual reports to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, Chairman Warren Buffett shows a table that pits his investment record against the Standard & Poor's 500 Index, the benchmark for most money managers.
This year, the reading will look like an aberration. For the first time since 1980, Buffett, widely cited as one of the world's shrewdest investors, won't beat the market.
Buffett compares the annual percentage increases in Berkshire Hathaway's book value -- and there have been nothing but gains starting with 1965 -- with gains and losses in the S&P 500. Berkshire's book value, or net worth, includes its earnings over the years, the market value of its stocks and bonds and adjustments for acquisitions.
At the end of this year, the holding company's book value will be $37,900 a share, gaining only imperceptibly from the year-earlier figure of $37,800 a share, according to an estimate by PaineWebber analyst Alice Schroeder. Schroeder, who made the estimate Nov. 15, says the final number will depend on what happens to the stocks Buffett owns between now and year-end.
So far in 1999, the return on the 500 stocks in the S&P index, including reinvestment of dividends, is 16%. No way for Buffett to catch up.
In his last bad year, Berkshire's gain in book value trailed the S&P's gain by 13 percentage points.
Based on Schroeder's estimate, Berkshire's record has improved in recent weeks. On Sept. 30, Berkshire's book value was $36,385 a share, less than at the end of 1998. A loss for the full year would be unthinkable in Omaha, Nebraska, Buffett's base.
The per-share figure is based on what Berkshire calls 'Class A equivalents.' The company also has Class B shares, worth 1/30th of a Class A share.
Paper losses
Buffett has had a bad year in bonds, as have most investors, because higher interest rates ate into the value of fixed-income securities. Berkshire owned $31.9 billion worth of bonds on Sept. 30 on which it had $619 million in unrealized losses, says analyst Schroeder.
Berkshire's bond investments have increased in recent years through the acquisition of General Re and the shares in Geico it didn't previously own. Insurance companies like these two are big bond investors.
It's also been a bad year for the stocks Buffett owns, though the overall stock market continues to forge ahead. Berkshire holds stakes of 8% in Coca-Cola, 8.5% in Gillette and 9% in Freddie Mac, which buys mortgages and packages them as asset-backed securities. All have declined so far in 1999, as have Walt Disney shares, another big Berkshire investment.
Buffett's Coca-Cola holding has dropped $1.4 billion this year, as of yesterday's close. Freddie Mac shares have declined 26%.
Those losses were offset in part by a year-to-date gain of about $2.8 billion in American Express shares. As of Sept. 30, Berkshire's unrealized stock gains had declined to $23.9 billion from $28.9 billion at the end of 1998, Schroeder says. Berkshire's stocks on that date had a total value of $34.8 billion, the analyst says.
Berkshire a buy?
Berkshire adjusts its stock and bond holdings to reflect current market value at the end of each quarter.
For the first nine months of 1999, Berkshire showed declines in both earnings from operations -- competition kept insurance premiums down - and realized investment gains. Net income fell to $1.5 billion, or $1,009 share, from $2.3 billion, or $1,822 a share in the same 1998 period.
Berkshire Hathaway's own shares this year have dropped to 55,000 from 70,000 at the end of 1998. Class B shares fell 16 today to $1,784, down from $2,350 at the end of last year.
As it has been with many other sensible investors, Buffett's returns have been held back in recent years because he refused to buy stocks in computer-related companies, which he says he doesn't understand. Can you imagine the sage of Omaha owning Yahoo?
Buffett's investing record remains top-drawer. Few mutual fund managers beat the S&P 500 in any year; Buffett did it 18 years in a row. The 69-year-old personifies the long-term investor impervious to periodic upsets.
Still, it will be interesting to see what Buffett has to say to his shareholders when they meet next spring. |