To: $Mogul who wrote (43683 ) 12/13/1999 3:12:00 AM From: vagabond Respond to of 108040
(OT) Re TIVO: Without venturing any opinion on how the stock will do in the near-term, I must say that I have a hard time understanding the enthusiasm for the product itself. Guess I must be horribly old-fashioned, but nothing I've read about TIVO so far convinces me that it's better than a VCR for the way I and most other people I know like to record programs. I'd probably feel differently if TIVO recorded its programs on some kind of removable/replaceable drive that allowed one to record several hours of programs, pull out the drive to save it for future viewing at one's leisure, and then stick in a new (and economical) drive to record further programs. In other words, if it offered the kind of storage-versatility of videotapes. And maybe that's in the works, down-the-road. But for now, as I understand it, you can only record 14 hours or so or programming (30 with some models) before the hard-drive is filled -- and then you HAVE to start watching (or erasing) some of it in order to clear space for additional recordings. Not very flexible, to my mind (I can easily record 10-12 hours of stuff in a single week, which I might want to watch weeks or months later -- but don't want to be forced to "view it or lose it" in order to be able to record additional material). Plus, of course, TIVO won't play any tapes rented from a video-store -- so you'd STILL need to have a VCR anyway, for that purpose. And, finally, TIVO's ability to pause/freeze/delay/playback programming in "real-time" seems to me like pretty much a gimmick with limited practical applications -- except, I'll admit, for die-hard sports addicts who use it for nothing but football or basketball games. I won't say it would NEVER come in handy for regular programming -- but that limited possibility certainly doesn't strike me as a good enough reason to buy the thing. Again, I'm not saying I don't think the stock will perform -- at least in the near-term. But I'll be very curious to see how these products really do in-the-marketplace -- and am tempted to think most people won't find them as attractive as the manufacturers hope... Just my 2c worth... Vagabond