To: James Clarke who wrote (9374 ) 12/20/1999 2:55:00 AM From: Tomato Respond to of 79003
Jim, I'd agree with you that a lot of the new nifty-fifty and internet stocks are ridiculously valued. Having said that, has there ever been a bear market without a recession and/or either inflation or deflation? I remember Marty Zweig's book, Winning on Wall Street , written around 1987, I think, saying that it took inflation, deflation, or Dow or S&P (can't remember which) P/Es over 20 to precipitate the Bear, but it seems he's forgotten his own advice and been bullish as the magic 20 number has been overtaken these last several years. And he's been right. What happened to bring about the last bear markets? 1990--there was a recession, I think. 1987: Guess you could say that was overvaluation, but a lot of people call that a big correction, since it didn't last very long. Precipitated by Jim Baker as I recall. 1973-74: Oil crisis. Any precedent for this market to crash? Another thing to remember is that the average p/e of a Value Line stock is something like 15, which isn't exactly nose-bleed territory. Of course, that only includes stocks with earnings, and I suppose you could argue that the non-earning stocks skew the results. One other thing to think about is the fact that only 28% of NYSE stocks were above their 200 day moving averages as of a couple weeks ago, which means we could be having or have had another stealth bear market similar to the one a few years ago. My stock pick for 2000 is WSP.V, a stock I've owned (unprofitably) for 3 years. It's a Canadian diamond stock trading around C$2.20 that should have the 2nd diamond mine in Canada in 2002 if things go on schedule. It's trading at a huge discount to its NPV which Deutche Bank estimates as $12-$15 or higher (at one point in the DB report the analyst suggests $25 or more is not unreasonable). They own 68% of a minimum of 16 million tonnes of kimberlite rock worth US $200+ per tonne (the deposit is open in 3 directions). They're covered by analysts at DB and Canaccord Capital. Of course, if the market crashes I don't think people are going to be buying diamonds, so I'll be screwed.;-)