SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Pastimes : Investment Chat Board Lawsuits -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Jeffrey S. Mitchell who wrote (94)1/4/2000 12:48:00 AM
From: Jeffrey S. Mitchell  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 12465
 
Re: ZixIt Corporation Initiates Lawsuit Against Visa

ZixIt Corporation Initiates Lawsuit Against Visa

DALLAS, Dec. 31 /PRNewswire/ -- ZixIt Corporation (Nasdaq: ZIXI) ("ZixIt") announced today that it has filed a lawsuit against Visa U.S.A., Inc. and Visa International Service Association (collectively "Visa") in state district court in Dallas. The suit alleges that Visa undertook a series of actions that interfered with ZixIt's business relationships and disparaged ZixIt, its products, its management, and its shareholders.

The suit alleges that Visa intentionally set out to destroy ZixIt's ability to market its ZixCharge Internet transaction authorization system, which competes against the MasterCard and Visa-owned Secure Electronic Transaction ("SET") system. ZixIt's suit alleges that within two days of learning about ZixIt's competitive technology, Visa initiated an attack against ZixIt.

The Visa actions were led by Visa's Vice President of Technology Research, Paul Guthrie. They included the posting of more than 400 messages, under at least seven aliases, on the Yahoo! ZixIt message board. These messages not only attacked ZixIt and ZixCharge -- but also promoted and recommended competitive companies in which Visa has substantial investment positions. Many of the postings were inaccurate, misleading, or absolutely false. The suit also alleges that, in addition to the messages, Visa was also working directly to discourage financial institutions from partnering with ZixIt.

David P. Cook, chief executive officer of ZixIt Corporation commented, "Visa's conduct in this matter has made a mockery of ethical and decent business practices. Their outrageous behavior has seriously damaged ZixIt and its shareholders."

The lawsuit, including exhibits, is available on the ZixIt home page at www.zixit.com.

Chronology Leading to Visa Lawsuit:

May 17, 1999 - ZixIt officials meet with MasterCard International and provide non-public details of the ZixCharge system, ZixIt's Internet transaction authorization system. MasterCard views ZixCharge as a competitor to the MasterCard and Visa-owned Secure Electronic Transaction ("SET") system.

May 19, 1999 - Visa begins a malicious campaign of posting anonymous messages on the Yahoo! ZixIt message board.

May 19, 1999 - November 22, 1999 - While ZixIt is negotiating business relationships with financial institutions, Visa posts more than 400 messages to the Yahoo! board -- averaging more than 3 per working day. The Yahoo! message board is widely read by ZixIt investors, potential investors, and potential ZixIt partners. It is the Internet equivalent of a specialized newspaper that is freely available to Internet users worldwide. At the same time, Visa is working to thwart ZixIt's marketing efforts to financial institutions. (See exhibit 4 on www.zixit.com/visa).

November 22, 1999 - After a lengthy investigation, including legal action by ZixIt to obtain information from Yahoo!, it is determined that Visa, acting under at least seven aliases, composed and transmitted the disparaging and intentionally harmful messages to the Yahoo! ZixIt message board. The aliases, such as "twenex," "stockerama," and "pluribus_unum" are designed to conceal the Visa involvement.

November 23, 1999 - ZixIt sends a letter to Visa demanding, among other things, that Visa cease the egregious conduct. The postings under the known aliases stopped this day. (See exhibit 2 on www.zixit.com/visa).

December 6, 1999 - Visa responds to ZixIt's letter with a single-page fax admitting that Guthrie was involved, but failing to directly accept responsibility, stating instead that the "use of aliases ... would have prevented anyone from associating [the postings] with Visa." (See exhibit 3 on www.zixit.com/visa).

November 23, 1999 - December 31, 1999 - Visa permits the damage to continue by failing to take even the simple remedial action of having the messages removed from the Yahoo! Internet message board.

December 17, 1999 - ZixIt receives an email message from a prospective financial institution partner. The email message indicates that the financial institution had "talked with two people at Visa" and that there were "Visa objections" regarding a proposed arrangement with ZixIt.

December 31, 1999 - ZixIt announces suit. (See Original Petition on www.zixit.com/visa).

Visa Message Postings:

A small sample of Visa quotes from the message board is shown below. All 400+ postings may be viewed on our Web site. (See exhibit 4 on www.zixit.com/visa).

Visa Quotes Regarding the ZixCharge System & SET:

"I have talked to both FI's [financial institutions] and merchants about ZixCharge."

"I am the person that top FI's [financial institutions] call to look at things like [ZixIt]"

" ... future credit card needing [digital signature] is also a decision of the credit card companies and not [ZixIt]. They [Visa and MasterCard] have their own system [SET] that is competitive to [ZixIt's] and therefore would never standardize on [ZixIt]'s."

"none of these financial institutions who [ZixIt] is so dependent on will touch them."

"SET is now been put forward as the solution, and is ready to go (look at www.setco.org for the status). When the fraud rates are high enough, the credit card companies, banks and merchants will demand SET."

"[ZixCharge is] a solution around something that customers don't care that much about (giving up personal info to merchants)"

"ZixCharge is DOA. Shorts, we've got a great one here."

"[ZixCharge has] no chance of success."

"Everything [ZixIt] has presented has been done well by someone else, and in many cases for years by strong consortiums [SET] of industry players."

"[ZixIt] depends on FIs [financial institutions], but FIs have already made the choice to go elsewhere [SET]. Seems like a short to me."

"SET is taking off big time, mainly because of credit card co rules and pricing advantages that [ZixIt] won't get."

Visa Quotes Regarding ZixIt Corporation and ZixIt's Stock:

"[ZixIt] is dead."

"biggest POS [piece of sh*t] overpriced stock around."

"ZIXI stock will plummet on every announcement by the company."

"[ZixIt] is a bigger piece of Sh*t ... and should be flushed?"

"you shouldn't be investing in this stock."

"why those bastard brokers get away with it."

"sell it while you can"

"a clear short at this price."

"a sure way to financial ruin."

Visa Quotes Regarding ZixIt Management:

"[ZixIt management] is full of it"

"[Cook] was too busy smoking a big fat cigar and laughing his a** off at folks like you who've bought into this hype."

"[ZixIt] is the result of a big April fools joke by Cook, or perhaps the outcome of a three day tequila binge and drunken-bet payoff with Sanchez. [member of the ZixIt board of directors]"

"[ZixIt management] pimped themselves to the US government"

Visa Quotes Regarding ZixIt Shareholders:

"white trash", "a fat liar", "Stupid", "inbred West Virginia hillbillies."

"clueless bastard", "fool", "miserable coward", "idiot"

"unbalanced", "go back to beating your wife"

Visa Quotes Regarding Brokerage Analysts Favorable to ZixIt Corporation:

"I do think [brokerage analyst name deleted] is one of the best analysts in the industry, but ... I couldn't believe how bad a job he has done [on ZixIt] ... he has completely lowered his quality. I don't know if that includes "kissing ass" ... I think his quality has suffered noticeably."

The complete list of message postings that have been found to-date and the full text of the lawsuit, including exhibits, are available through the ZixIt home page at www.zixit.com.

ZixIt Corporation is the developer and owner of ZixIt(TM) Digital Signature and encryption technology. Products currently under development include: ZixMail(TM), a secure Internet-messaging system; and ZixCharge(TM), an Internet transaction authorization system. For further investor information about ZixIt, visit the company's Web sit at www.zixit.com or contact investor relations at 972-702-7057.

SOURCE ZixIt Corporation

CONTACT: Beverly V. Fuortes of ZixIt Corporation, 972-702-7057, or email, invest@zixit.com; or press, John Crowe of Public Strategies, Inc., 512-474-8848, or email, jcrowe@pstrategies.com, for ZixIt Corporation/

corporate-ir.net



To: Jeffrey S. Mitchell who wrote (94)7/31/2002 1:32:01 PM
From: Arcane Lore  Respond to of 12465
 
Wednesday July 31, 1:27 pm Eastern Time

Press Release

SOURCE: ZixIt Corp.

ZixIt Announces Jury Decision in Its Lawsuit Against Visa

DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--July 31, 2002--ZixIt Corp. (Nasdaq:ZIXI - News), a global provider of secure e-messaging services, today announced that a jury decided against the company in a lawsuit filed in December 1999 against Visa USA, Inc. and Visa International Service Association (collectively, "Visa"), Case No. 99-10187 before the 192nd Judicial District Court in Dallas County, Texas. In the lawsuit, ZixIt alleged that Visa undertook a series of actions that interfered with prospective business relationships for ZixCharge(TM), ZixIt's secure authorization payment system for online transactions, and disparaged ZixIt, its products, its management, and its stockholders.

About ZixIt Corp.

ZixIt Corp. is a global provider of secure e-messaging services, providing innovative, cost-effective and easy-to-deploy solutions that ensure the highest levels of security for corporate email and other electronic messages. ZixIt's security suite enables organizations to leverage email as a mission-critical application that can be used efficiently and securely for even the most sensitive electronic messages and content. Additional information about ZixIt can be found at www.zixit.com.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Contact:

MS&L
Financial Media
Cindy Lawrence, 212/213-7484
cindy.lawrence@mslpr.com
or
ZixIt
Investor Contact
Beverly V. Fuortes, 214/515-7357
invest@zixit.com

biz.yahoo.com



To: Jeffrey S. Mitchell who wrote (94)8/1/2002 9:38:07 AM
From: Arcane Lore  Respond to of 12465
 
From the Dallas Morning News:

Zixit suit against Visa fails

08/01/2002

By CRAYTON HARRISON / The Dallas Morning News

Zixit Corp. lost its lawsuit Wednesday against Visa USA Inc., when a jury found that the credit card giant had not plotted to defame the company.

Shares of Zixit, the Dallas developer of encryption technology, fell $2.84, or nearly 50 percent, to $2.95 Wednesday.

Visa conceded that a former vice president in charge of technology research, Paul Guthrie, had used aliases on message boards to make statements about Zixit's encryption technology for credit card transactions.

But the jury found that Mr. Guthrie was acting on his own.

The jury also dismissed Zixit's accusation that its stock price was hurt because of conversations Visa employees had with Wachovia National Bank and MBNA North America NA, clients Zixit was pursuing.

Zixit chief executive John Ryan said he hasn't yet explored all the legal options, but the company probably won't seek an appeal.

"I strongly suspect that this chapter is closed," he said. "It has little or nothing to do with the great opportunities we have."

E-mail charrison@dallasnews.com

dallasnews.com



To: Jeffrey S. Mitchell who wrote (94)7/7/2003 3:12:42 PM
From: Arcane Lore  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 12465
 
Message 19090189



To: Jeffrey S. Mitchell who wrote (94)7/7/2003 4:07:28 PM
From: Jeffrey S. Mitchell  Respond to of 12465
 
Re: 6/03 - [ZIXI] Law.com: ZixIt Corp. v. Visa USA Inc.

DEFAMATION

'So What?' Defense Turns Back Visa Suit

CASE TYPE: defamation
CASE: ZixIt Corp. v. Visa USA Inc. and Visa International Service Association Inc., No. 99-10187-K (Dallas Co., Texas, Dist. Ct.)
PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEYS: Neal S. Manne, Kenneth E. McNeil, Stuart V. Kusin from the Houston office of Susman Godfrey, and Barry C. Barnett from Susman Godfrey's Dallas office.
DEFENSE ATTORNEYS: Michael P. Lynn, Jeffrey M. Tillotson and Aldolfo R. Rodriguez Jr. of Lynn Tillotson & Pinker of Dallas
JURY VERDICT: for the defense

Defense attorney Michael P. Lynn promised jurors that they would dislike one of his most important witnesses. The man at the heart of the defamation case they were hearing might very well be the worst witness ever, the attorney warned the Dallas jury.

And that witness—Paul Guthrie, Visa's former vice president of technology and research—didn't disappoint. He fidgeted, appeared to lie and evaded questions, Lynn said. Guthrie's unimpressive showing could have been the death knell for the defense, but it apparently didn't sway jurors.

The panel awarded nothing to ZixIt Corp., which had claimed that Visa—with Guthrie as its agent—defamed the Internet credit-card-clearing center with more than 400 postings on Internet message boards that trashed the start-up.

ZixIt was vying with giant Visa for customers for the same concept, encryption of credit cardholders' identification information on the Internet. ZixIt's lawyers showed that Guthrie had used a half-dozen pseudonyms on Yahoo! message boards to criticize the company. He accused ZixIt of hyping its stock and being unable to deliver the services it promised.

The plaintiffs alleged that Guthrie's 437 messages, posted in 1999 from his Visa office and San Francisco home, sabotaged investor confidence in ZixIt's product and defamed the company. They sought $701 million in damages, reflecting the loss in value of the company's stock and lost profits. The defense honed its strategy in four mock trials.

"We found that if we tried to distance ourselves from Guthrie and claim [Visa had] no responsibility for his actions, the jury was angry," Lynn said. "But if we took responsibility, the jury was angry." The defense team opted to use a "so what?" defense—"he did it but it didn't cause any harm"—Lynn said. He showed a film clip of 50,000 cheering fans and explained that "the voice of Paul Guthrie was not unlike one person screaming in a stadium." Defense attorneys also presented a causation expert who testified that there was no connection between ZixIt's stock activity and Guthrie's postings.

Jurors deliberated for three-and-a-half days before returning a 10-2 verdict in favor of the defense. They said after the trial that they disliked Guthrie but did not feel he was acting at Visa's behest. Plaintiff's attorney Neal S. Manne of Susman Godfrey's Houston office said the defense won because its attorneys were "incredibly effective." If he'd had his way, he would have forced ZixIt to accept a multimillion-dollar settlement offer made at the trial's start.

law.com