To: bob zagorin who wrote (29955 ) 1/8/2000 12:29:00 PM From: Henry Niman Respond to of 32384
Two case studies: DR. HYMES: Good morning. Thank you, Dr. Reich. I'd like to present 2 patients who were enrolled on the Targretin study in my institution not only from the perspective of an investigator, but also from the perspective of a physician who cares for a larger number of patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. I have over 200 patients in my practice who I'm actively following with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma and see 1 to 2 new patients per week. The first patient I'd like to present is a 67-year-old woman with a history of stage IIB cutaneous T-cell lymphoma with a 10 and one-half year history of disease duration. There was 70 percent body surface area involvement with plaques, patches, and tumors, as well as three large cutaneous tumors, which the photographs will reflect. She's been refractory to previous treatments, including topical nitrogen mustard, as well as refractory to treatment with systemic interferon alpha 2B at doses of 7 and a half to 10 million units 3 times per week. This is the appearance of a large tumor on her right forearm at baseline. Following 12 weeks of therapy, there was significant flattening of the tumor. The bi-dimensional measurements of this area have not changed, but of course, there's actually a significant reduction in the total volume. At week 28, the skin had returned to normal texture with only some residual hypopigmentation. I would like to point out that based upon the very conservative composite assessment lesions, there would still be a tumor score despite the apparent major clinical response because of residual hypopigmentation. This is a lesion on the top of her scalp. If you notice, it's actually two large necrotic tumors which are communicating underneath a bridge of normal skin. This lesion is referred to in the letter which this patient submitted in the open public hearing. She described this tumor as being quite odoriferous to the extent that her grandchildren would not want to ride in the same automobile with her. I'd also like point out that because of the location, this would not be immediately apparent in hemi-body photographs. Nonetheless, the localized photographs show that at week 12 there was significant healing with a replacement of the tumor with granulation tissue. At week 41, the scar is barely visible under normal regrowth of her hair. If we're to look at the assessments based upon protocol endpoints, she achieved a 50 percent improvement, the definition for response based on physician's global assessment, and the composite assessment ratio determined independently at week 8. In summary, she had a 75 percent response, 75 percent improvement of her skin, with a duration of greater than 2 years. The body surface area involvement reduced from 70 percent to 12 percent. The three cutaneous tumors present at baseline all completely resolved. Interestingly, because dose reduction and concomitant medications were required to control hypertriglyceridemia, there was the appearance of a new tumor measuring 1.1 centimeters with dose reduction. This was in an area previously uninvolved with a cutaneous tumor. With dose increase, the tumor again resolved. The second patient I'd like to present is a 58-year-old woman with stage III cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. There was a 2-year duration of disease. She was erythrodermic with 100 percent body surface area involvement. There were two clinically abnormal lymph nodes, and her previous treatment included refractoriness to interferon, as well as refractoriness to high dose methotrexate with leucovorin rescue. Photographs of her arm showed thickening and erythema of the skin at baseline. By week 12, there was a reduction erythema. By week 36, the texture of the skin and the color of the skin had returned to normal. This improvement is not a photographic artifact. This was reflected in my personal clinical assessment of this patient. Similar improvement was noted on her back with the hypertrophic erythematous skin becoming paler and assuming more color and texture by week 36. There was good correlation between the composite assessment ratio and the physician's global assessment ratio, with the patient achieving a 50 percent improvement in both by week 16, and it being sustained and consistent improvement by up to 52 weeks on this slide. In fact, the patient has a 65 to 75 percent response based on the PGA and the CA over 2.2 years, and the patient continues on medication. Her complaints of pruritus, alopecia, and nail changes fully cleared. There were two nodes at baseline which completely resolved, as well as toxicity defined as elevated triglycerides requiring dose reduction and administration of medication. Since cutaneous T-cell lymphoma is a chronic, symptomatic, incurable, and relapsing disease, patients with this disease will require a sequence of multiple different therapies. Targretin is impressive because it has a very high single agent response rate in patients refractory to drugs which are ordinarily our only agents useful in this disease. The safety profile is qualitatively different from other treatments for cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, providing an advantage in avoiding cumulative and overlapping toxicities. The common toxicities, hypertriglyceridemia and hypothyroidism, can be easily controlled with medications that most physicians are familiar with using. The ease of oral administration eliminates the need for travel to centers for PUVA, electron beam therapy, or photopheresis. And the long duration of response is particularly impressive in this heavily pretreated group of patients.