To: Julian who wrote (826 ) 2/16/2000 11:40:00 PM From: Ian@SI Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 1321
Julian, TD Securities analyst has been Bearish and wrong on QLT since it was $10/share. I've never known a less competent analyst in any sector, ever. The analyst has never once shown an understanding of the diseases being treated, the efficacy of QLT's treatment relative to the alternatives, nor any potential for this company. And anyone following his advice has been made poorer. Anyone using him as a contrarian indicator has been greatly enriched. Christine Charest definitely outclasses this mental midget. FWIW, Ian. Latest report that I could see was from Nov 9th... +++++++++++ Hari Sambasivam Company Profile Current Price: Shares O/S (mm): 12-Month Target Price: Share Float (mm): 24-Month Target Price: Market Cap (mm): Outlook/Recommendation 12-Month Potential Return: 52-Week Range: 24-Month Potential Return: Year-End Dec 31 1995A 1996A 1997A 1998A 1999E 2000E Valuation Drivers ($mm) Cash Reserves $11.8 $97.2 $86.9 $78.2 $228.8 $234.3 Cash Burn Rate $15.0 $9.7 $8.1 $28.9 $28.9 -$7.5 R&D Expenses $12.1 $11.5 $19.2 $23.9 $27.0 $29.7 Profitability EPS ($0.39) ($0.10) ($0.32) ($0.45) ($0.57) $0.09 Valuation Capital Structure Total Assets (mm) $22.8 $112.2 $86.9 $103.2 Total Debt (mm) $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 Shareholders? Equity (mm) $21.2 $108.9 $94.8 $95.1 Debt/Total Cap 0.0x 0.0x 0.0x 0.0x Current Assets (mm) $13.9 $107.8 $94.2 $93.3 Current Liabilities (mm) $1.6 $3.3 $6.4 $8.1 Latest Developments Quick Facts (Figures in Canadian dollars, unless otherwise noted.) Financial Summary (Figures in Canadian dollars, unless otherwise noted.) QLT PhotoTherapeutics Inc. (QLT-T, M; QLTI-Q) November 9, 1999 Recommendation: HOLD $51.50 $48.50 $60.50 64.0 64.0 $3,297 $11.88 - $67.30 -6% 17% TSE 300 Weight: 0.540% QLT is a leader in the field of photodynamic therapy. Its first product, PHOTOFRIN, has been approved for selected oncological indications. However, QLT?s main opportunity is for Visudyne, which is aimed at treating Age-related Macular Degeneration (AMD). QLT?s stock value is driven primarily by the prospects for Visudyne in the treatment of AMD. Phase III trials (TAP trial; 2 studies in the U.S. and Europe; 609 patients and 22 centres) in previously untreatable patients with blood vessel formation beneath the fovea (key retinal area) showed encouraging data for Visudyne. Visudyne elicited stable/improved vision (loss of less than 3 lines of vision in a standard eye chart) in 61.4% of patients vs. 45.9% for placebo (34% improvement; statistically significant), with a greater difference anticipated after 2 years of therapy. Improved vision (1 line or more) is seen in 16% of treated patients vs. 7% on placebo. The data demonstrated good safety and efficacy in patients with predominantly classic lesions after 1 year of therapy. Our valuation suggests a target price of $48.50, using 2002E EPS of $2.73, a P/E multiple of 30 (given the opportunity for growth of Visudyne) and a discount factor of 30%. The stock is rated as a HOLD due to recent increases, but a Long-Term BUY given upcoming milestones and sparse near-term competition for Visudyne. QLT?s losses per share for Q3/99 and 9M/99 were ($0.15) and ($0.36), respectively and were consistent with our estimate of ($0.57) for 1999. Expenses for Q3/99 included QLT?s share of the pre-marketing costs for Visudyne ($3.95mm). The campaign to educate users re: Visudyne is proceeding well with: (1) 109 of 200 lasers placed; (2) granting of a temporary reimbursement code in the U.S.; and (3) education of Medicare-related reimbursement agencies. Photofrin sales in Q3/99 were slow at $1.9mm (same as Q3/98). PHOTOFRIN received further European approvals assisted by its approval in the UK. Accrual for PHOTOFRIN?s phase III trial for Barrett?s Esophagus has been completed with data expected in Q4/00. Near-term milestones for Visudyne include the FDA advisory committee meeting on 17 Nov and the release in Q2/00 of 2-year data from the TAP trial and the data from the VIP trial. Our rating remains a HOLD pending analysis of initial Visudyne revenues in the U.S.