To: MikeM54321 who wrote (6465 ) 3/15/2000 6:36:00 AM From: MikeM54321 Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 12823
Re: SBC Using FCC 99-238 to their Advantage Thread- I consider what SBC is doing a significant strategy in the on going battle between data-CLECs and RBOCs as DSL services rollout. IMO the article is difficult to understand, but the concept is easy. SBC is running packet switching (Voice over ATM) out to their remote gateways, neighborhood nodes, field cabinets, mini-COs, etc...This does to things. I'm not sure which is more important. First, it virtually makes it impossible for the data-CLEC to line share but not for the reasons the article states. IMO, it's more of a physical problem. How do you line share at a remote terminal? And it appears to fall under rule 99-238. RBOC's don't have to line share packet switched lines. A double block of a data-CLECs entry into the SBC customer base. Secondly, it allows SBC to bring fiber into the neighborhood for a higher data rate to their customers. Hopefully allowing SBC to supply cable TV like services over their copper plant. -MikeM(From Florida) PS My next posts details FCC 99-238. ******************************SBC SQUARES OFF AGAINST CLECS OVER DSL ACCESS Critics Fear Project Pronto Thwarts Competition March 14, 2000-- A fight is quietly brewing over the future of DSL that promises to equal the 1996 battle over the interconnection regime. Oddly, SBC Communication's Project Pronto is touching off the war. The $6 billion DSL-network upgrade, a landmark on SBC's map of its broadband future, has CLECs furious. Think of SBC and the CLECs as the U.S.-Russian alliance during World War II -- a coalition of natural antagonists, one of which thinks its ally is secretly planning an empire. But this is telecom, of course, so don't look for anything as dramatic as a Berlin blockade. SBC's opening salvo was a dry Feb. 15 request that the FCC interpret its conditions on the SBC-Ameritech merger so as to allow SBC to own DSL line cards in the gateways being built as part of Project Pronto. That relatively uncontroversial issue exploded after data CLECs got a look at SBC's design for its DSL network. SBC's plan is to push fiber as far out the network as possible, with fiber-fed "neighborhood gateways" aggregating copper local DSL loops. So far, so good. The primary limitation of DSL is the length of the local loop. The further the signal travels on fiber, the more customers will be able to reach it. And SBC is offering to make the line cards an unbundled network element, possibly the first case in history of an ILEC volunteering a new UNE. But the gateways, or "remote terminals," will require SBC-specified, Alcatel [ALA]-made line cards to connect the fiber and copper. CLECs say that will prevent them from offering any type of DSL other than ADSL. Worse, they fear the gateway proposal is a Trojan horse, a plausible offering that conceals a host of future, proprietary limitations. "This could be just the tip of the iceberg," says John Windhausen Jr., president of the Association for Local Telecom Services, a Washington-based trade association representing CLECs. Trade Organizations Unite Against Proposal ALTS, the Global Alliance for Telecom and the DSL Access Telecom Alliance all have questioned SBC's plan and said the ILEC is rushing it through the FCC in a process so expedited that CLECs can't properly assess the design. SBC says CLECs shouldn't judge the design. "ALTS wants to dictate the construction of a private network," says SBC spokesman Matt Miller. "They want to dictate the way we spend $6 billion to bring DSL to millions. Frankly, that's ridiculous." The CLEC fears, however, are widespread. GAT told the FCC that RBOCs are "thumbing their noses at the FCC and its policy." DATA, an alliance of Rhythms NetConnections [RTHM], Covad [COVD] and Northpoint [NPNT], said an all-SBC UNE would be "competition lite," killing facility-based competition. Launched last fall, the Project Pronto initiative would make DSL available to 80 percent of SBC customers by 2002, which represents 77 million people. As of February, more than 12 million homes and businesses were able to receive SBC's DSL services, company officials say. The company plans to add the service to 300 additional markets by year-end, through its subsidiaries. At its current pace, SBC expects to exceed its initial goal of 16 million DSL-eligible homes and business at the end of 2000. -- Paul Coe Clark III