To: Villemure who wrote (31199 ) 4/25/2000 2:01:00 AM From: Scott C. Lemon Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 42771
Hello Giacomini, I have a couple of comments about the ScheMax announcement ... both good and bad. First, I'll start with the good news ... Novell is finally giving something away for free which should have been free a long time ago! We talked about it on this board, and I have yelled for it to be free ... and now it is! This is actually a very good thing. Novell has realized that instead of trying to milk some customer a ton of money for a tool that helps people use the directory, and put information into the directory they are going to provide it for free. This is called the "razor and razorblade" model ... make it easy for people to add information into a directory, so that you can charge them for the numerous applications that will *use* this information later! But now we get to a more critical issue that I feel Novell needs to address. And that is their confusion about what they have of value ... and, IMHO, it's *not* the directory. It's the directory-enabled applications. While working on digitalme, I spent a considerable amount of time thinking and talking with the engineers on the project. One of the "revelations" that hit me one day was that the "schema", or naming and organization of information, was the most important issue. The fact that we both call the 'attributes" the same name. Where Novell did not take advantage of this announcement is in the formation of an organization with their customers to define "standard" schema for various industries and purposes. This is *exactly* what Microsoft has done with BizTalk. If Novell were to involve their customers from the various industry segments, they could create the standard "schema packs" which would be the attributes of users in these various industries. They could then provide the ScheMax definitions, and would create a huge "de facto" standard moving forward, which they could mix with the various standards efforts. IMHO, this is a "strategy" that could be pursued ... what I see is a "tactical" announcement. I'm glad to see it, but it appears to be tactical ... ;-( On another note, I suggest that you go and try to download the app. It is amazing to me that Novell requires so much form-filling and information just to get a tool! They have a form that requires numerous fields and questions to be answered. Come on! This is a *FREE* product that can't be used on anything but a NetWare system with NDS! Why be so determined to "mine" me for information? Let me get it, and if I want anything else out of you - like service or support - you can ask questions then! You already know your registered users and developers! And it doesn't seem to work if you don't allow cookies! I haven't seen any other site that is so "invasive" when offering free products. .. Oh well ... like I said ... good and bad. I have to say that the product *is* one of the best out there - acquired with the Netoria acquisition. Very cool stuff ... Scott C. Lemon