To: Tomato who wrote (10448 ) 4/28/2000 12:40:00 AM From: James Clarke Respond to of 78958
EBSC - You want to probability weight four outcomes: 1) The stock continues to putter along in the 4-6 range until we all give up in disgust. 2) There is some real problem (credit sub?) that we're all missing, and we're looking at a $2 stock when the big holders pull the rip-cord and there's nobody to buy. 3) Management LBOs the company for $6-7. 4) A buyer is found in the $8-10 range. Unless you assign a big probability to #2, I really like the odds at a price below $5, especially given the pressure already on management to do #3 or #4. The new 10-K should be available to the masses tomorrow (I haven't seen it yet, but others did today - if the whole retail sector weren't getting crushed today I would not have bought because I would have concluded there was something in that 10-K that caused a big holder to dump. Maybe there was. But more likely, we were looking at "its an illiquid retailer, sell it" dump.) A close read of the 10-K may give a clearer idea of what the weight of #2 should be. I think my takeout values are conservative - remember, book value is $16, it trades way below net current assets, the company is profitable and there are several large shareholders to negotiate on our behalf to get a fair price out of the buyer. But with the price at 4 and change, no sensible bidder is going to pay his full price unless there is somebody else bidding against him (and right now I'd be thrilled to see one bidder). When I saw the price drop to 4 1/4 today I had the "punch in the gut" feeling that is usually a great buy signal. But if I see it at 3 1/2 tomorrow, that will be the "knife in the gut" feeling and I'm not sure what that means.