To: Seeker of Truth who wrote (5204 ) 6/2/2000 12:34:00 PM From: manohar kanuri Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 6018
Spot on about quasi-democracy! There was that news item about a young woman in the UK who was flunked at the interview for Magdalen College for the egregious error of being from the wrong class, and then won a hefty grant to go to Harvard. This goes back to Jay's comment about who runs China -- some genuinely good people, some thugs and a third group I don't recall now. Framed thus, the so-called democracies of Asia and Europe fit that description quite nicely. The Chinese thug aspires to a place on the Politburo, the British thug aims for a knighthood. Fact remains, the average Jane/Joe born on the "wrong" side of the tracks has a higher probability of translating their political and legal rights into social and material advancement in the US than in older societies. If we take obstacles on the road to advancement as the benchmark, I'm not sure "democratic" France, UK or India have that much of an edge over communist China. The first three are not as egalitarian as they might like to be because their entrenched systems of privilege simply evolved and adapted to a democratic mould. I'm willing to hazard the guess that China, having dismantled those systems and moved right along for a couple of generations, will wind up being much more egalitarian when it goes democratic than most other countries. In some senses it probably is already. Putting aside value judgements about the nature of the system itself, the average American or the average Chinese who is willing to follow the rules of the system is not handicapped, like the average Indian or Brit, by the facts of birth, class and caste. I suppose one can talk about egalitarian communism or capitalism on the one hand, and feudal bourgeoisies struggling to be egalitarian democracies on the other. "..... Whose spurred feet have crossed From left to right the blank page of the road? Reading from left to right in winter's code: A dot, an arrow pointing back; repeat: Dot, arrow pointing back ... A pheasant's feet! Torquated beauty, sublimated grouse Finding your China right behind my house. Was he in Sherlock Holmes , the fellow whose Tracks pointed back when he reversed his shoes?" Certain gentlemen formerly of Cornell, if no one else, should recognize that quote. :) yep, gotta love this thread....no vulgar thread police bludgeoning all interesting conversation out of it! mk