To: IQBAL LATIF who wrote (31707 ) 6/4/2000 8:26:00 PM From: Shtirlitz Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 50167
Great post. And you are absolutely right, The economy will most likely keep growing for a while even if it is a slower pace. There is no recession on a horizon yet. However,... Economy is one thing and stocks are a completely different story. Lets look five years back and try to understand what has really happened to the stock prices. The old argument, which I feel is very appropriate to raise again. The economy output has grown about 35% during the past 5 years. At the same time stock indexes have grown 200%+. Where did this growth come from? Obviously from the expanded multiples and premiums we are seeing in the stock prices today. S&P premiums have increased on average by 70+%, which pretty much makes up for the missing numbers. Increase in premiums seemed to be appropriate, when the economy was accelerating its growth. Now the situation has changed dramaticaly. The growth is slowing, and any acceleration attempt will be met by agressive Fed policies. Which means that if the economy cannot catch up to the stock prices, the stock prices should come back to the reality, or at least wait. This "asset bubble" has to be resolved sooner or later. That is my point. I don't see the room for the future growth in stock prices. Any unrealistic expectations will not be fullfiled. Productivity growth is also not eternal. You can give a worker a computer instead of paper and filing cabinet, but you can't make him type faster. Are we getting close to the top of the equipment upgrade cycle, which has started 5 years ago ? Frankly I'm surprized that the market ignored the low and much lower than expected productivity growth last quarter. Because if not for productivity, this market doesn't have a bull case at all. So where is the point, when you decide thasts'it. I don't want to pay higher premiums. This is the hardest question. But stocks are certainly becoming an unattractive investment. Too much risk, volatility, uncertainty. And thats not considering the fact, that they are pretty pricey. Where in this market do you see value ? Everyone is recommending financials lately. But look at them, they are trading at huge premiums to book value, when 2 is already a very richly valued ratio. No matter how great AXP or C look, I think that paying 7 Price/book for them is a great stretch to say the least. I'm not even talking about techs here. PEG ratios of 10+ are not something that attracts me as investor. Are we at the point when the liqudity will start leaving this volatile market, or the stock chasing mania is about to continue ? I don't know. I'm staying in this market as a trader, But my investment capital isn't coming back into this market, despite of any promisses of a big "summer rally". This is traders market. And as a trader I love it, but as an investor I hate it. So most likely I would expect liquidity to start leaving it on any run-ups. And leave this market to maniac traders, who are thriving in this volatility. Support for this market by large investors is drying out. Investors are getting scared away by the maniac casino type market action and questionable fundamentals. And this is a big problem.