To: IQBAL LATIF who wrote (31796 ) 6/9/2000 10:12:00 AM From: IQBAL LATIF Respond to of 50167
<<Focus: Microsoft May Benefit from Relief Rally; Analysts Remain Bullish MICHAEL TODD PAI NEW YORK (AFX) - Microsoft Corp shares may benefit from a relief rally following yesterdays widely-expected court ruling to split the company into two separate entities, with analysts remaining largely bullish on the company, dealers said. Prudential Securities Doug Crook said the ruling "should come as no surprise" and added "the issuing of a final ruling may relieve some of the pressure," as sentiment has been dragged down during the case by negative press reports surrounding the case. Crook reiterated his strong buy rating on the shares and 90 usd 12-month price target. George Godfrey at ING Barings agreed that "the worst news is out". "We expect any news coming out of the appeals process should be better by comparison," Godfrey said. Godfrey reiterated a strong buy recommendation on Microsoft shares and maintained a 135 usd price target. Although Goldman Sachs Rick Sherlund believes the shares will see "some upside" and regain some lost ground in a relief rally on the ruling, he does not expect the share price to return to previous highs. "Business is still rather sluggish, so we would not expect the stock to return to earlier high levels, but could perhaps sustain a 10 or 20 percent rally of the next few quarters," he said. Sherlund, who maintained a market outperformer rating, noted the stock could see "sharp" declines from current levels if an appeals court holds up the breakup ruling. Mary Meeker at Morgan Stanley Dean Witter said she is "relieved to see the case move to the next phase of its potentially long life". Meeker, however, continues "to look for longer-term catalysts such as a possible settlement to the case that would not include a breakup or, on a more fundamental level, an improvement in corporate PC demand, increased deployments of Windows 2000 and Microsofts Forum 2000 on June 22." Once the case reaches the appellate level, the chances increase that Microsoft and the government will restart negotiations, Meeker said, noting if that does not happen, the case could "drag on" for at least another 1-2 years. Meeker reiterated her outperform rating. Microsoft stands a "good chance" of winning an appeal, according to the ING Barings analyst, who said the company stands a 50/50 chance of winning the appeal case. While Microsoft is "most valuable" as a single company and a breakup would negatively impact its worth, Godfrey said he believes "that even broken-up, the combined pieces would still be worth more than where the stock is trading today, especially as the contribution from Windows 2000 has an increasing impact on revenue growth." Prudentials Crook agreed "shareholder value would be released if the company were to be broken up," with a split into two companies resulting in a 75 usd valuation in the stock today. A breakup into three companies could, however, unlock even more shareholder value, Crook said. He estimates a break out of Microsofts internet-related consumer, commerce and other properties could add an additional 35 usd to the share price, for a total breakup value of 110 usd a share. However, Sherlund at Goldman Sachs said his view of a breakup has been "pretty negative" and he remains "concerned" about the impact if the company were to actually be split. "We believe if one were to do a sum-of-the-parts analysis, it would show a valuation that is about 10 percent less than the current share price," Sherlund said. A duplication of Microsofts administrative and sales costs in a breakup scenario could negatively impact earnings by "about 5 percent or so," he added. The company could also face staff problems, Sherlund said, noting most staff and management would elect to join the applications company in light of the "severe" restrictions that would be placed on the operating systems company. Among other analysts commenting on Microsoft, Deutsche Banc Alex Brown reiterated a buy rating on their "assumption that Microsoft will not be broken up"; Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrettes Joseph Farley maintained a buy rating and 140 usd price target, saying the shares offer "compelling" value at current levels. Lehman Brothers also reiterated a buy rating. >>