SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Pastimes : Deadheads -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: SIer formerly known as Joe B. who wrote (21042)6/16/2000 11:48:00 AM
From: SIer formerly known as Joe B.  Respond to of 49843
 
Getting Persuaded, III


sfgate.com:80/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2000/06/15/DD57064.DTL

THE PERSUASIONS HAVE two
basic modes for recording a track for
an album.

The first is to make it as close to a
live performance as possible, all five
in the studio together singing a
cappella.

They listen to the playback, do it a
few more times, then each singer
does small fixes on the phrasings and
pitches.

The second mode, more common on
ballads, is for Jerry Lawson, the lead
singer, and Jimmy Hayes, the bass, to
record the song by themselves. When
they get a version they like -- and that
rarely takes long, because they are
prepared when they arrive -- then the
two tenors (Joe Russell and Raymond
Sanders) put in their harmonies, one
by one, followed by Jayotis
Washington, the baritone.

The second method was in effect for
the recording of ``Ripple,'' an early
Grateful Dead song from the
``American Beauty'' album. (For
those who came in late: The
Persuasions are recording an entire
album of Grateful Dead songs, to be
called ``Might as Well'' and to be
released in October.)

Some of us who enjoy the Grateful
Dead only selectively and
occasionally think of ``Ripple'' as
being perhaps a little too far toward
the ``Desiderata''/haplessly
hoping/sandalwood-candles end of
the spectrum, despite Robert Hunter's
fine lyrics.

But I had already heard the
Persuasions open up other Grateful
Dead songs. Jerry Lawson had picked
``Ripple'' as one of the 14 songs for
the album from a list of 35 or so
submitted by producers Rip Rense
and David Gans, as well as by Hunter
himself. So he had an idea.

JERRY LAWSON IS a large man in
every way, but his voice can be
delicate and even modest, serving the
lyrics by letting them fall clearly
against the melody line. I watched in
the control room with the others as
he started singing, supported and
urged along by Hayes' gentle bass.

``If my words did glow with the gold
of sunshine,'' he started, and the
silence in the room became deeper. It
was like watching a cathedral being
built.

At the end of the song, the silence
was so long that Lawson finally said,
``Was that OK?'' David Gans pressed
the talk-back button. ``We're all just
stunned in here, Jerry. That was
beautiful.''

Rense said: ``You know what we
should do? We should leave it just
like that. No other parts. It's perfect.
Why mess with perfection?''

AND THAT'S MORE or less what
happened. In the final version, it's just
the two voices for the first three
verses. Then, two-thirds of the way
through the song, at ``There is a
road,'' Russell joins in with the first
harmony part, and two lines later
Sanders comes in on a higher line. By
the words ``Ripple in still water,''
Washington has joined the mix, and
it's a Persuasions song.

Over the next few days, Gans and
Lawson added other elements to the
last 45 seconds of the song -- a taste
of dobro, a pluck of mandolin. When
the all-woman a cappella group Mary
Schmary came into the studio to add
tracks to ``Might as Well'' (which
includes a voice-generated trumpet
solo from Alyn Kelley), they also
recorded harmonies for the last 15
seconds of ``Ripple,'' which is mostly
``la la la . . .''

Mary Schmary are not backup singers;
they do not sound like the typical trio
that stands at the edge of the stage
doing little fills for the star. Their
blend is not angelic; in this mix, they
sound more muscular than the
Persuasions.

It's a collaboration that sounds like a
collaboration; it is infected by its own
process. Its final line, sung by nine
voices, is both a promise and the
fulfillment of a promise: ``If I knew
the way, I would take you home.''

All that in three minutes and seven
seconds. Magic.

Sometimes it's like pulling teeth;
sometimes it's like drinking honey.

Reach out your hand if your cup be
jrc@sfgate.com.


ú Printer-friendly version
ú Email this article to a
friend

Backflip this page
to find it again

Jon Carroll's Fine
Home Page

Getting
Persuaded, III
06/15/2000

Getting
Persuaded, II
06/14/2000

Getting
Persuaded
06/13/2000

Jon Carroll
Archives:



Feedback




¸2000 San Francisco Chronicle Page E12



To: SIer formerly known as Joe B. who wrote (21042)6/16/2000 11:50:00 AM
From: JakeStraw  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 49843
 
The Persuasions covered Zappa so why not the Dead?! I wonder if they'll do a cappella versions of "Space" & "Drums"?? :^)